William Howard Taft
State of the Union Address
December 6, 1910
To the Senate and House of Representatives:
During the past year the foreign relations of the United States have
continued upon a basis of friendship and good understanding.
The year has been notable as witnessing the pacific settlement of two
important international controversies before the Permanent Court of The
The arbitration of the Fisheries dispute between the United States and
Great Britain, which has been the source of nearly continuous diplomatic
correspondence since the Fisheries Convention of 1818, has given an award
which is satisfactory to both parties. This arbitration is particularly
noteworthy not only because of the eminently just results secured, but
also because it is the first arbitration held under the general arbitration
treaty of April 4, 1908, between the United States and Great Britain, and
disposes of a controversy the settlement of which has resisted every other
resource of diplomacy, and which for nearly ninety years has been the cause
of friction between two countries whose common interest lies in maintaining
the most friendly and cordial relations with each other.
The United States was ably represented before the tribunal. The complicated
history of the questions arising made the issue depend, more than ordinarily
in such cases, upon the care and skill with which our case was presented,
and I should be wanting in proper recognition of a great patriotic service
if I did not refer to the lucid historical analysis of the facts and the
signal ability and force of the argument --six days in length--presented
to the Court in support of our case by Mr. Elihu Root. As Secretary of
State, Mr. Root had given close study to the intricate facts bearing on
the controversy, and by diplomatic correspondence had helped to frame the
issues. At the solicitation of the Secretary of State and myself, Mr. Root,
though burdened by his duties as Senator from New York, undertook the preparation
of the case as leading counsel, with the condition imposed by himself that,
in view of his position as Senator, he should not receive any compensation.
The Tribunal constituted at The Hague by the Governments of the United
States and Venezuela has completed its deliberations and has rendered an
award in the case of the Orinoco Steamship Company against Venezuela. The
award may be regarded as satisfactory since it has, pursuant to the contentions
of the United States, recognized a number of important principles making
for a judicial attitude in the determining of international disputes.
In view of grave doubts which had been raised as to the constitutionality
of The Hague Convention for the establishment of an International Prize
Court, now before the Senate for ratification, because of that provision
of the Convention which provides that there may be an appeal to the proposed
Court from the decisions of national courts, this government proposed in
an Identic Circular Note addressed to those Powers who had taken part in
the London Maritime Conference, that the powers signatory to the Convention,
if confronted with such difficulty, might insert a reservation to the effect
that appeals to the International Prize Court in respect to decisions of
its national tribunals, should take the form of a direct claim for compensation;
that the proceedings thereupon to be taken should be in the form of a trial
de novo, and that judgment of the Court should consist of compensation
for the illegal capture, irrespective of the decision of the national court
whose judgment had thus been internationally involved. As the result of
an informal discussion it was decided to provide such procedure by means
of a separate protocol which should be ratified at the same time as the
Prize Court Convention itself.
Accordingly, the Government of the Netherlands, at the request of this
Government, proposed under date of May 24, 1910, to the powers signatory
to The Hague Convention, the negotiation of a supplemental protocol embodying
stipulations providing for this alternative procedure. It is gratifying
to observe that this additional protocol is being signed without objection,
by the powers signatory to the original convention, and there is every
reason to believe that the International Prize Court will be soon established.
The Identic Circular Note also proposed that the International Prize
Court when established should be endowed with the functions of an Arbitral
Court of Justice under and pursuant to the recommendation adopted by the
last Hague Conference. The replies received from the various powers to
this proposal inspire the hope that this also may be accomplished within
the reasonably near future.
It is believed that the establishment of these two tribunals will go
a long way toward securing the arbitration of many questions which have
heretofore threatened and, at times, destroyed the peace of nations.
Appreciating these enlightened tendencies of modern times, the Congress
at its last session passed a law providing for the appointment of a commission
of five members "to be appointed by the President of the United States
to consider the expediency of utilizing existing international agencies
for the purpose of limiting the armaments of the nations of the world by
international agreement, and of constituting the combined navies of the
world an international force for the preservation of universal peace, and
to consider and report upon any other means to diminish the expenditures
of government for military purposes and to lessen the probabilities of
I have not as yet made appointments to this Commission because I have
invited and am awaiting the expressions of foreign governments as to their
willingness to cooperate with us in the appointment of similar commissions
or representatives who would meet with our commissioners and by joint action
seek to make their work effective.
GREAT BRITAIN AND CANADA.
Several important treaties have been negotiated with Great Britain in
the past twelve months. A preliminary diplomatic agreement has been reached
regarding the arbitration of pecuniary claims which each Government has
against the other. This agreement, with the schedules of claims annexed,
will, as soon as the schedules are arranged, be submitted to the Senate
An agreement between the United States and Great Britain with regard
to the location of the international boundary line between the United States
and Canada in Passamaquoddy Bay and to the middle of Grand Manan Channel
was reached in a Treaty concluded May 21, 1910, which has been ratified
by both Governments and proclaimed, thus making unnecessary the arbitration
provided for in the previous treaty of April 11, 1908.
The Convention concluded January 11, 1909, between the United States
and Great Britain providing for the settlement of international differences
between the United States and Canada including the apportionment between
the two countries of certain of the boundary waters and the appointment
of Commissioners to adjust certain other questions has been ratified by
both Governments and proclaimed.
The work of the International Fisheries Commission appointed in 1908,
under the treaty of April 11, 1908, between Great Britain and the United
States, has resulted in the formulation and recommendation of uniform regulations
governing the fisheries of the boundary waters of Canada and the United
States for the purpose of protecting and increasing the supply of food
fish in such waters. In completion of this work, the regulations agreed
upon require congressional legislation to make them effective and for their
enforcement in fulfillment of the treaty stipulations.
In October last the monarchy in Portugal was overthrown, a provisional
Republic was proclaimed, and there was set up a de facto Government which
was promptly recognized by the Government of the United States for purposes
of ordinary intercourse pending formal recognition by this and other Powers
of the Governmental entity to be duly established by the national sovereignty.
A disturbance among the native tribes of Liberia in a portion of the
Republic during the early part of this year resulted in the sending, under
the Treaty of 1862, of an American vessel of war to the disaffected district,
and the Liberian authorities, assisted by the good offices of the American
Naval Officers, were able to restore order. The negotiations which have
been undertaken for the amelioration of the conditions found in Liberia
by the American Commission, whose report I transmitted to Congress on March
25 last, are being brought to conclusion, and it is thought that within
a short time practical measures of relief may be put into effect through
the good offices of this Government and the cordial cooperation of other
governments interested in Liberia's welfare.
THE NEAR EAST.
To return the visit of the Special Embassy announcing the accession
of His Majesty Mehemet V, Emperor of the Ottomans, I sent to Constantinople
a Special Ambassador who, in addition to this mission of ceremony, was
charged with the duty of expressing to the Ottoman Government the value
attached by the Government of the United States to increased and more important
relations between the countries and the desire of the United States to
contribute to the larger economic and commercial development due to the
new regime in Turkey.
The rapid development now beginning in that ancient empire and the marked
progress and increased commercial importance of Bulgaria, Roumania, and
Servia make it particularly opportune that the possibilities of American
commerce in the Near East should receive due attention.
The National Skoupchtina having expressed its will that the Principality
of Montenegro be raised to the rank of Kingdom, the Prince of Montenegro
on August 15 last assumed the title of King of Montenegro. It gave me pleasure
to accord to the new kingdom the recognition of the United States.
THE FAR EAST.
The center of interest in Far Eastern affairs during the past year has
again been China.
It is gratifying to note that the negotiations for a loan to the Chinese
Government for the construction of the trunk railway lines from Hankow
southward to Canton and westward through the Yangtse Valley, known as the
Hukuang Loan, were concluded by the representatives of the various financial
groups in May last and the results approved by their respective governments.
The agreement, already initialed by the Chinese Government, is now awaiting
formal ratification. The basis of the settlement of the terms of this loan
was one of exact equality between America, Great Britain, France, and Germany
in respect to financing the loan and supplying materials for the proposed
railways and their future branches.
The application of the principle underlying the policy of the United
States in regard to the Hukuang Loan, viz., that of the internationalization
of the foreign interest in such of the railways of China as may be financed
by foreign countries, was suggested on a broader scale by the Secretary
of State in a proposal for internationalization and commercial neutralization
of all the railways of Manchuria. While the principle which led to the
proposal of this Government was generally admitted by the powers to whom
it was addressed, the Governments of Russia and Japan apprehended practical
difficulties in the execution of the larger plan which prevented their
ready adherence. The question of constructing the Chinchow-Aigun railway
by means of an international loan to China is, however, still the subject
of friendly discussion by the interested parties.
The policy of this Government in these matters has been directed by
a desire to make the use of American capital in the development of China
an instrument in the promotion of China's welfare and material prosperity
without prejudice to her legitimate rights as an independent political
This policy has recently found further exemplification in the assistance
given by this Government to the negotiations between China and a group
of American bankers for a loan of $50,000,000 to be employed chiefly in
currency reform. The confusion which has from ancient times existed in
the monetary usages of the Chinese has been one of the principal obstacles
to commercial intercourse with that people. The United States in its Treaty
of 1903 with China obtained a pledge from the latter to introduce a uniform
national coinage, and the following year, at the request of China, this
Government sent to Peking a member of the International Exchange Commission,
to discuss with the Chinese Government the best methods of introducing
the reform. In 1908 China sent a Commissioner to the United States to consult
with American financiers as to the possibility of securing a large loan
with which to inaugurate the new currency system, but the death of Their
Majesties, the Empress Dowager and the Emperor of China, interrupted the
negotiations, which were not resumed until a few months ago, when this
Government was asked to communicate to the bankers concerned the request
of China for a loan of $50,000,000 for the purpose under review. A preliminary
agreement between the American group and China has been made covering the
For the success of this loan and the contemplated reforms which are
of the greatest importance to the commercial interests of the United States
and the civilized world at large, it is realized that an expert will be
necessary, and this Government has received assurances from China that
such an adviser, who shall be an American, will be engaged.
It is a matter of interest to Americans to note the success which is
attending the efforts of China to establish gradually a system of representative
government. The provincial assemblies were opened in October, 1909, and
in October of the present year a consultative body, the nucleus of the
future national parliament, held its first session at Peking.
The year has further been marked by two important international agreements
relating to Far Eastern affairs. In the Russo-Japanese Agreement relating
to Manchuria, signed July 4, 1910, this Government was gratified to note
an assurance of continued peaceful conditions in that region and the reaffirmation
of the policies with respect to China to which the United States together
with all other interested powers are alike solemnly committed.
The treaty annexing Korea to the Empire of Japan, promulgated August
29, 1910, marks the final step in a process of control of the ancient empire
by her powerful neighbor that has been in progress for several years past.
In communicating the fact of annexation the Japanese Government gave to
the Government of the United States assurances of the full protection of
the rights of American citizens in Korea under the changed conditions.
Friendly visits of many distinguished persons from the Far East have
been made during the year. Chief among these were Their Imperial Highnesses
Princes Tsai-tao and Tsai-Hsun of China; and His Imperial Highness Prince
Higashi Fushimi, and Prince Tokugawa, President of the House of Peers of
Japan. The Secretary of War has recently visited Japan and China in connection
with his tour to the Philippines, and a large delegation of American business
men are at present traveling in China. This exchange of friendly visits
has had the happy effect of even further strengthening our friendly international
During the past year several of our southern sister Republics celebrated
the one hundredth anniversary of their independence. In honor of these
events, special embassies were sent from this country to Argentina, Chile,
and Mexico, where the gracious reception and splendid hospitality extended
them manifested the cordial relations and friendship existing between those
countries and the United States, relations which I am happy to believe
have never before been upon so high a plane and so solid a basis as at
The Congressional commission appointed under a concurrent resolution
to attend the festivities celebrating the centennial anniversary of Mexican
independence, together with a special ambassador, were received with the
highest honors and with the greatest cordiality, and returned with the
report of the bounteous hospitality and warm reception of President Diaz
and the Mexican people, which left no doubt of the desire of the immediately
neighboring Republic to continue the mutually beneficial and intimate relations
which I feel sure the two governments will ever cherish.
At the Fourth Pan-American Conference which met in Buenos Aires during
July and August last, after seven weeks of harmonious deliberation, three
conventions were signed providing for the regulation of trade-marks, patents,
and copyrights, which when ratified by the different Governments, will
go far toward furnishing to American authors, patentees, and owners of
trade-marks the protection needed in localities where heretofore it has
been either lacking or inadequate. Further, a convention for the arbitration
of pecuniary claims was signed and a number of important resolutions passed.
The Conventions will in due course be transmitted to the Senate, and the
report of the Delegation of the United States will be communicated to the
Congress for its information. The special cordiality between representative
men from all parts of America which was shown at this Conference cannot
fail to react upon and draw still closer the relations between the countries
which took part in it.
The International Bureau of American Republics is doing a broad and
useful work for Pan American commerce and comity. Its duties were much
enlarged by the International Conference of American States at Buenos Aires
and its name was shortened to the more practical and expressive term of
Pan American Union. Located now in its new building, which was specially
dedicated April 26 of this year to the development of friendship, trade
and peace among the American nations, it has improved instrumentalities
to serve the twenty-two republics of this hemisphere.
I am glad to say that the action of the United States in its desire
to remove imminent danger of war between Peru and Ecuador growing out of
a boundary dispute, with the cooperation of Brazil and the Argentine Republic
as joint mediators with this Government, has already resulted successfully
in preventing war. The Government of Chile, while not one of the mediators,
lent effective aid in furtherance of a preliminary agreement likely to
lead on to an amicable settlement, and it is not doubted that the good
offices of the mediating Powers and the conciliatory cooperation of the
Governments directly interested will finally lead to a removal of this
perennial cause of friction between Ecuador and Peru. The inestimable value
of cordial cooperation between the sister republics of America for the
maintenance of peace in this hemisphere has never been more clearly shown
than in this mediation, by which three American Governments have given
to this hemisphere the honor of first invoking the most far-reaching provisions
of The Hague Convention for the pacific settlement of international disputes.
There has been signed by the representatives of the United States and
Mexico a protocol submitting to the United States-Mexican Boundary Commission
(whose membership for the purpose of this case is to be increased by the
addition of a citizen of Canada) the question of sovereignty over the Chamizal
Tract which lies within the present physical boundaries of the city of
E1 Paso, Tex. The determination of this question will remove a source of
no little annoyance to the two Governments.
The Republic of Honduras has for many years been burdened with a heavy
bonded debt held in Europe, the interest on which long ago fell in arrears.
Finally conditions were such that it became imperative to refund the debt
and place the finances of the Republic upon a sound basis. Last year a
group of American bankers undertook to do this and to advance funds for
railway and other improvements contributing directly to the country's prosperity
and commerce--an arrangement which has long been desired by this Government.
Negotiations to this end have been under way for more than a year and it
is now confidently believed that a short time will suffice to conclude
an arrangement which will be satisfactory to the foreign creditors, eminently
advantageous to Honduras, and highly creditable to the judgment and foresight
of the Honduranean Government. This is much to be desired since, as recognized
by the Washington Conventions, a strong Honduras would tend immensely to
the progress and prosperity of Central America.
During the past year the Republic of Nicaragua has been the scene of
internecine struggle. General Zelaya, for seventeen years the absolute
ruler of Nicaragua, was throughout his career the disturber of Central
America and opposed every plan for the promotion of peace and friendly
relations between the five republics. When the people of Nicaragua were
finally driven into rebellion by his lawless exactions, he violated the
laws of war by the unwarranted execution of two American citizens who had
regularly enlisted in the ranks of the revolutionists. This and other offenses
made it the duty of the American Government to take measures with a view
to ultimate reparation and for the safeguarding of its interests. This
involved the breaking off of all diplomatic relations with the Zelaya Government
for the reasons laid down in a communication from the Secretary of State,
which also notified the contending factions in Nicaragua that this Government
would hold each to strict accountability for outrages on the rights of
American citizens. American forces were sent to both coasts of Nicaragua
to be in readiness should occasion arise to protect Americans and their
interests, and remained there until the war was over and peace had returned
to that unfortunate country. These events, together with Zelaya's continued
exactions, brought him so clearly to the bar of public opinion that he
was forced to resign and to take refuge abroad.
In the above-mentioned communication of the Secretary of State to the
Charge' d'Affaires of the Zelaya Government, the opinion was expressed
that the revolution represented the wishes of the majority of the Nicaraguan
people. This has now been proved beyond doubt by the fact that since the
complete overthrow of the Madriz Government and the occupation of the capital
by the forces of the revolution, all factions have united to maintain public
order and as a result of discussion with an Agent of this Government, sent
to Managua at the request of the Provisional Government, comprehensive
plans are being made for the future welfare of Nicaragua, including the
rehabilitation of public credit. The moderation and conciliatory spirit
shown by the various factions give ground for the confident hope that Nicaragua
will soon take its rightful place among the law-abiding and progressive
countries of the world.
It gratifies me exceedingly to announce that the Argentine Republic
some months ago placed with American manufacturers a contract for the construction
of two battle-ships and certain additional naval equipment. The extent
of this work and its importance to the Argentine Republic make the placing
of the bid an earnest of friendly feeling toward the United States.
The new tariff law, in section 2, respecting the maximum and minimum
tariffs of the United States, which provisions came into effect on April
1, 1910, imposed upon the President the responsibility of determining prior
to that date whether or not any undue discrimination existed against the
United States and its products in any country of the world with which we
sustained commercial relations.
In the case of several countries instances of apparent undue discrimination
against American commerce were found to exist. These discriminations were
removed by negotiation. Prior to April 1, 1910, when the maximum tariff
was to come into operation with respect to importations from all those
countries in whose favor no proclamation applying the minimum tariff should
be issued by the President, one hundred and thirty-four such proclamations
were issued. This series of proclamations embraced the entire commercial
world, and hence the minimum tariff of the United States has been given
universal application, thus testifying to the satisfactory character of
our trade relations with foreign countries.
Marked advantages to the commerce of the United States were obtained
through these tariff settlements. Foreign nations are fully cognizant of
the fact that under section 2 of the tariff act the President is required,
whenever he is satisfied that the treatment accorded by them to the products
of the United States is not such as to entitle them to the benefits of
the minimum tariff of the United States, to withdraw those benefits by
proclamation giving ninety days' notice, after which the maximum tariff
will apply to their dutiable products entering the United States. In its
general operation this section of the tariff law has thus far proved a
guaranty of continued commercial peace, although there are unfortunately
instances where foreign governments deal arbitrarily with American interests
within their jurisdiction in a manner injurious and inequitable.
The policy of broader and closer trade relations with the Dominion of
Canada which was initiated in the adjustment of the maximum and minimum
provisions of the Tariff Act of August, 1909, has proved mutually beneficial.
It justifies further efforts for the readjustment of the commercial relations
of the two countries so that their commerce may follow the channels natural
to contiguous countries and be commensurate with the steady expansion of
trade and industry on both sides of the boundary line. The reciprocation
on the part of the Dominion Government of the sentiment which was expressed
by this Government was followed in October by the suggestion that it would
be glad to have the negotiations, which had been temporarily suspended
during the summer, resumed. In accordance with this suggestion the Secretary
of State, by my direction, dispatched two representatives of the Department
of State as special commissioners to Ottawa to confer with representatives
of the Dominion Government. They were authorized to take such steps for
formulating a reciprocal trade agreement as might be necessary and to receive
and consider any propositions which the Dominion Government might care
Pursuant to the instructions issued conferences were held by these commissioners
with officials of the Dominion Government at Ottawa in the early part of
The negotiations were conducted on both sides in a spirit of mutual
accommodation. The discussion of the common commercial interests of the
two countries had for its object a satisfactory basis for a trade arrangement
which offers the prospect of a freer interchange for the products of the
United States and of Canada. The conferences were adjourned to be resumed
in Washington in January, when it is hoped that the aspiration of both
Governments for a mutually advantageous measure of reciprocity will be
FOSTERING FOREIGN TRADE.
All these tariff negotiations, so vital to our commerce and industry,
and the duty of jealously guarding the equitable and just treatment of
our products, capital, and industry abroad devolve upon the Department
The Argentine battle-ship contracts, like the subsequent important one
for Argentine railway equipment, and those for Cuban Government vessels,
were secured for our manufacturers largely through the good offices of
the Department of State.
The efforts of that Department to secure for citizens of the United
States equal opportunities in the markets of the world and to expand American
commerce have been most successful. The volume of business obtained in
new fields of competition and upon new lines is already very great and
Congress is urged to continue to support the Department of State in its
endeavors for further trade expansion.
Our foreign trade merits the best support of the Government and the
most earnest endeavor of our manufacturers and merchants, who, if they
do not already in all cases need a foreign market, are certain soon to
become dependent on it. Therefore, now is the time to secure a strong position
in this field.
AMERICAN BRANCH BANKS ABROAD.
I cannot leave this subject without emphasizing the necessity of such
legislation as will make possible and convenient the establishment of American
banks and branches of American banks in foreign countries. Only by such
means can our foreign trade be favorably financed, necessary credits be
arranged, and proper avail be made of commercial opportunities in foreign
countries, and most especially in Latin America.
AID TO OUR FOREIGN MERCHANT MARINE.
Another instrumentality indispensable to the unhampered and natural
development of American commerce is merchant marine. All maritime and commercial
nations recognize the importance of this factor. The greatest commercial
nations, our competitors, jealously foster their merchant marine. Perhaps
nowhere is the need for rapid and direct mail, passenger and freight communication
quite so urgent as between the United States and Latin America. We can
secure in no other quarter of the world such immediate benefits in friendship
and commerce as would flow from the establishment of direct lines Of communication
with the countries of Latin America adequate to meet the requirements of
a rapidly increasing appreciation of the reciprocal dependence of the countries
of the Western Hemisphere upon each other's products, sympathies and assistance.
I alluded to this most important subject in my last annual message;
it has often been before you and I need not recapitulate the reasons for
its recommendation. Unless prompt action be taken the completion of the
Panama Canal will find this the only great commercial nation unable to
avail in international maritime business of this great improvement in the
means of the world's commercial intercourse.
Quite aside from the commercial aspect, unless we create a merchant
marine, where can we find the seafaring population necessary as a natural
naval reserve and where could we find, in case of war, the transports and
subsidiary vessels without which a naval fleet is arms without a body?
For many reasons I cannot too strongly urge upon the Congress the passage
of a measure by mail subsidy or other subvention adequate to guarantee
the establishment and rapid development of an American merchant marine,
and the restoration of the American flag to its ancient place upon the
Of course such aid ought only to be given under conditions of publicity
of each beneficiary's business and accounts which would show that the aid
received was needed to maintain the trade and was properly used for that
FEDERAL PROTECTION TO ALIENS.
With our increasing international intercourse, it becomes incumbent
upon me to repeat more emphatically than ever the recommendation which
I made in my Inaugural Address that Congress shall at once give to the
Courts of the United States jurisdiction to punish as a crime the violation
of the rights of aliens secured by treaty with the United States, in order
that the general government of the United States shall be able, when called
upon by a friendly nation, to redeem its solemn promise by treaty to secure
to the citizens or subjects of that nation resident in the United States,
freedom from violence and due process of law in respect to their life,
liberty and property.
MERIT SYSTEM FOR DIPLOMATIC AND CONSULAR SERVICE.
I also strongly commend to the favorable action of the Congress the
enactment of a law applying to the diplomatic and consular service the
principles embodied in Section 1753 of the Revised Statutes of the United
States, in the Civil Service Act of January 16, 1883, and the Executive
Orders of June 27, 1906, and of November 26, 1909. The excellent results
which have attended the partial application of Civil Service principles
to the diplomatic and consular services are an earnest of the benefit to
be wrought by a wider and more permanent extension of those principles
to both branches of the foreign service. The marked improvement in the
consular service during the four years since the principles of the Civil
Service Act were applied to that service in a limited way, and the good
results already noticeable from a similar application of civil service
principles to the diplomatic service a year ago, convince me that the enactment
into law of the general principles of the existing executive regulations
could not fail to effect further improvement of both branches of the foreign
service, offering as it would by its assurance of permanency of tenure
and promotion on merit, an inducement for the entry of capable young men
into the service and an incentive to those already in to put forth their
best efforts to attain and maintain that degree of efficiency which the
interests of our international relations and commerce demand.
GOVERNMENT OWNERSHIP OF OUR EMBASSY AND LEGATION PREMISES.
During many years past appeals have been made from time to time to Congress
in favor of Government ownership of embassy and legation premises abroad.
The arguments in favor of such ownership have been many and oft repeated
and are well known to the Congress. The acquisition by the Government of
suitable residences and offices for its diplomatic officers, especially
in the capitals of the Latin-American States and of Europe, is so important
and necessary to an improved diplomatic service that I have no hesitation
in urging upon the Congress the passage of some measure similar to that
favorably reported by the House Committee on Foreign Affairs on February
14, 1910 (Report No. 438), that would authorize the gradual and annual
acquisition of premises for diplomatic use.
The work of the Diplomatic Service is devoid of partisanship; its importance
should appeal to every American citizen and should receive the generous
consideration of the Congress.
ESTIMATES FOR NEXT YEAR'S EXPENSES.
Every effort has been made by each department chief to reduce the estimated
cost of his department for the ensuing fiscal year ending June 30, 1912.
I say this in order that Congress may understand that these estimates thus
made present the smallest sum which will maintain the departments, bureaus,
and offices of the Government and meet its other obligations under existing
law, and that a cut of these estimates would result in embarrassing the
executive branch of the Government in the performance of its duties. This
remark does not apply to the river and harbor estimates, except to those
for expenses of maintenance and the meeting of obligations under authorized
contracts, nor does it apply to the public building bill nor to the navy
building program. Of course, as to these Congress could withhold any part
or all of the estimates for them without interfering with the discharge
of the ordinary obligations of the Government or the performance of the
functions of its departments, bureaus, and offices.
A FIFTY-TWO MILLION CUT.
The final estimates for the year ending June 30, 1912, as they have
been sent to the Treasury, on November 29 of this year, for the ordinary
expenses of the Government, including those for public buildings, rivers
and harbors, and the navy building program, amount to $630,494,013.12.
This is $52,964,887.36 less than the appropriations for the fiscal year
ending June 30, 1911. It is $16,883,153.44 less than the total estimates,
including supplemental estimates submitted to Congress by the Treasury
for the year 1911, and is $5,574,659.39 less than the original estimates
submitted by the Treasury for 1911.
These figures do not include the appropriations for the Panama Canal,
the policy in respect to which ought to be, and is, to spend as much each
year as can be economically and effectively expended in order to complete
the Canal as promptly as possible, and, therefore, the ordinary motive
for cutting down the expense of the Government does not apply to appropriations
for this purpose. It will be noted that the estimates for the Panama Canal
for the ensuing year are more than fifty-six millions of dollars, an increase
of twenty millions over the amount appropriated for this year--a difference
due to the fact that the estimates for 1912 include something over nineteen
millions for the fortification of the Canal. Against the estimated expenditures
of $630,494,013.12, the Treasury has estimated receipts for next year $680,000,000,
making a probable surplus of ordinary receipts over ordinary expenditures
of about $50,000,000.
A table showing in detail the estimates and the comparisons referred
The Treasury Department is one of the original departments of the Government.
With the changes in the monetary system made from time to time and with
the creation of national banks, it was thought necessary to organize new
bureaus and divisions which were added in a somewhat haphazard way and
resulted in a duplication of duties which might well now be ended. This
lack of system and economic coordination has attracted the attention of
the head of that Department who has been giving his time for the last two
years, with the aid of experts and by consulting his bureau chiefs, to
its reformation. He has abolished four hundred places in the civil service
without at all injuring its efficiency. Merely to illustrate the character
of the reforms that are possible, I shall comment on some of the specific
changes that are being made, or ought to be made by legislative aid.
The auditing system in vogue is as old as the Government and the methods
used are antiquated. There are six Auditors and seven Assistant Auditors
for the nine departments, and under the present system the only function
which the Auditor of a department exercises is to determine, on accounts
presented by disbursing officers, that the object of the expenditure was
within the law and the appropriation made by Congress for the purpose on
its face, and that the calculations in the accounts are correct. He does
not examine the merits of the transaction or determine the reasonableness
of the price paid for the articles purchased, nor does he furnish any substantial
check upon disbursing officers and the heads of departments or bureaus
with sufficient promptness to enable the Government to recoup itself in
full measure for unlawful expenditure. A careful plan is being devised
and will be presented to Congress with the recommendation that the force
of auditors and employees under them be greatly reduced, thereby effecting
substantial economy. But this economy will be small compared with the larger
economy that can be effected by consolidation and change of methods. The
possibilities in this regard have been shown in the reduction of expenses
and the importance of methods and efficiency in the office of the Auditor
for the Post Office Department, who, without in the slightest degree impairing
the comprehensiveness and efficiency of his work, has cut down the expenses
of his office $120,000 a year.
Statement of estimates of appropriations for the fiscal years 1912 and
1911, and of appropriations for 1911, showing increases and decreases.
Final Estimates for 1912 as of November 29 Original Estimates submitted
by the Treasury for 1911 Total Estimates for 1911 including supplementals
Appropriations for 1911 Increase (+) and decrease (-), 1912 estimates against
1911 total estimates Increase (+) and decrease (-), 1912 estimates against
1911 total appropriations Increase (+) and decrease (-), 1911 estimates
against 1911 total appropriations
Legislature $13,426,805.73 $13,169,679.70 $13,169,679.70 $12,938,048.00
+ $257,126.03 + $488,757.73 + $231,631.70
Executive 998,170.00 472,270.00 722,270.00 870,750.00 +
275,900.00 + 127,420.00 - 148,480.00
State Department: 4,875,576.41 4,875,301.41 4,749,801.41 5,046,701.41
+ 125,775.00 - 171,125.00 -
Treasury Department proper 68,735,451.00 69,865,240.00 70,393,543.75
69,973,434.61 - 1,658,092.75 - 1,237,983.61 +
Public buildings and works 11,864,545.60 6,198,365.60 7,101,465.60
5,565,164.00 + 4,763,080.00 + 6,299,381.60 + 1,536,301.60
Territorial governments 202,150.00 287,350.00 292,350.00 282,600.00
- 90,200.00 -
80,450.00 + 9,750.00
Independent offices 2,638,695.12 2,400,695.12 2,492,695.12 2,128,695.12
+ 146,000.00 + 510,000.00 +
District of Columbia 13,602,785.90 11,884,928.49 12,108,878.49 11,440,346.99
+ 1,492,907.41 + 2,162,439.91 + 668,532.50
War Department proper 120,104,260.12 124,165,656.28 125,717,204.77
122,322,178.12 - 5,612,944.65 - 2,217,918.00 + 3,395,026.65
Rivers and harbors 28,232,438.00 28,232,465.00 28,232,465.00 49,390,541.50
- 27.00 -21,158,103.50
Navy Department proper 116,101,730.24 117,029,914.38 119,768,860.83
119,596,870.46 - 3,667,130.59 - 3,495,140.22 + 171,990.37
New navy building program 12,840,428.00 12,844,122.00 12,844,122.00
14,790,122.00 - 3,694.00 -
1,949,694.00 - 1,946,000.00
Interior Department 189,151,875.00 191,224,182.90 193,948,582.02 214,754,278.00
- 4,796,707.02 -25,602,403.00 -20,805,698.98
Post-Office Department proper 1,697,490.00 1,695,690.00 1,695,690.00
2,085,005.33 + 1,800.00 -
387,515.33 - 389,315.33
Deficiency in postal revenues --------------- 10,634,122.63 10,634,122.63
10,634,122.63 -10,634,122.65 -10,634,122.63 -----------------
Department of Agriculture 19,681,066.00 17,681,136.00 17,753,931.24
17,821,836.00 + 1,927,134.76 + 1,859,230.00 -
Department of Commerce and
Labor 16,276,970.00 14,187,913.00 15,789,271.00 14,169,969.32
+ 487,699.00 + 2,107,000.68 + 1,619,301.68
Department of Justice 10,063,576.00 9,518,640.00 9,962,233.00 9,648,237.99
+ 101,343.00 + 415,338.01 +
Total ordinary 630,494,013.12 636,068,672.51 647,377,166.56 683,458,900.48
-16,883,153.44 -52,964,887.36 -36,081,733.92
Panama Canal 56,920,847.69 48,063,524.70 52,063,524.70 37,855,000.00
+ 4,857,322.99 +19,065,847.69 +14,208,524.70
Total 687,414,860.81 684,132,197.21 699,440,691.26 721,313,900.48 -12,025,830.45
Again, in the collection of the revenues, especially the customs revenues,
a very great improvement has been effected, and further improvements are
contemplated. By the detection of frauds in weighing sugar, upwards of
$3,400,000 have been recovered from the beneficiaries of the fraud, and
an entirely new system free from the possibilities of such abuse has been
devised. The Department has perfected the method of collecting duties at
the Port of New York so as to save the Government upwards of ten or eleven
million dollars; and the same spirit of change and reform has been infused
into the other customs offices of the country.
The methods used at many places are archaic. There would seem to be
no reason at all why the Surveyor of the Port, who really acts for the
Collector, should not be a subordinate of the Collector at a less salary
and directly under his control, and there is but little reason for the
existence of the Naval Officer, who is a kind of local auditor. His work
is mainly an examination of accounts which is conducted again in Washington
and which results in no greater security to the Government. The Naval Officers
in the various ports are Presidential appointees, many of them drawing
good salaries, and those offices should be abolished or with reduced force
made part of the central auditing system.
There are entirely too many customs districts and too many customs collectors.
These districts should be consolidated and the collectors in charge of
them, who draw good salaries, many of them out of proportion to the collections
made, should be abolished or treated as mere branch offices, in accordance
with the plan of the Treasury Department, which will be presented for the
consideration of Congress. As an illustration, the cost of collecting $1
of revenue at typical small ports like the port of York, Me., was $50.04.
At the port of Annapolis, Md., it cost $309.41 to collect $1 of revenue;
at Natchez, $52.76; at Alexandria. Va., $122.49.
It is not essential to the preventing of smuggling that customs districts
should be increased in number. The violation of the customs laws can be
quite as easily prevented, and much more economically, by the revenue-cutter
service and by the use of the special agent traveling force of the Treasury
Department. A reorganization of the special customs agents has been perfected
with a view to retaining only those who have special knowledge of the customs
laws, regulations, and usual methods of evasion, and with this improvement,
there will be no danger to the Government from the recommended consolidation
and abolition of customs districts.
An investigation of the appraising system now in vogue in New York
City has shown a sacrifice of the interests of the Government by under-appraisement,
which is in the course of being remedied by reorganization and the employment
of competent experts. Prosecutions have been instituted growing out of
the frauds there discovered and are now awaiting hearing in the Federal
Very great improvements have been made in respect to the mints and assay
offices. Diminished appropriations have been asked for those whose continuance
is unnecessary, and this year's estimate of expenses is $326,000 less than
two years ago. There is an opportunity for further saving in the abolition
of several mints and assay offices that have now become unnecessary. Modern
machinery has been installed there, more and better work has been done,
and the appropriations have been consequently diminished.
In the Bureau of Engraving and Printing, great economies have been effected.
Useless divisions have been abolished with the result of saving $440,000
this year in the total expenses of the Bureau despite increased business.
The Treasurer's office and that of the Division of Public Moneys in
part cover the same functions and this is also true of the office of the
Register and the Division of Loans and Currency. Plans for the elimination
of the duplication in these offices will be presented to Congress.
COMPTROLLER OF THE CURRENCY.
The office of the Comptroller of the Currency is one most important
in the preservation of proper banking methods in the national banking system
of the United States, and the present Comptroller has impressed his subordinates
with the necessity of so conducting their investigations as to establish
the principle that every bank failure is unnecessary because proper inspection
and notice of threatening conditions to the responsible directors and officers
can prevent it.
In our public buildings we still suffer from the method of appropriation,
which has been so much criticized in connection with our rivers and harbors.
Some method should be devised for controlling the supply of public buildings,
so that they will harmonize with the actual needs of the Government. Then,
when it comes to the actual construction, there has been in the past too
little study of the building plans and sites with a view to the actual
needs of the Government. Post-Office buildings which are in effect warehouses
for the economical handling of transportation of thousands of tons of mail
have been made monumental structures, and often located far from the convenient
and economical spot. In the actual construction of the buildings, a closer
scrutiny of the methods employed by the Government architects or by architects
employed by the Government have resulted in decided economies. It is hoped
that more time will give opportunity for a more thorough reorganization.
The last public building bill carried authorization for the ultimate expenditure
of $33,011,500 and I approved it because of the many good features it contained,
just as I approved the river and harbor bill, but it was drawn upon a principle
that ought to be abandoned. It seems to me that the wiser method of preparing
a public building bill would be the preparation of a report by a commission
of Government experts whose duty it should be to report to Congress the
Government's needs in the way of the construction of public buildings in
every part of the country, just as the Army Engineers make report with
reference to the utility of proposed improvements in rivers and harbors,
with the added function which I have recommended for the Army Engineers
of including in their recommendation the relative importance of the various
projects found to be worthy of approval and execution.
As the Treasury Department is the one through which the income of the
Government is collected and its expenditures are disbursed, this seems
a proper place to consider the operation of the existing tariff bill, which
became a law August 6, 1909. As an income-producing measure, the existing
tariff bill has never been exceeded by any customs bill in the history
of the country.
The corporation excise tax, proportioned to the net income of every
business corporation in the country, has worked well. The tax has been
easily collected. Its prompt payment indicates that the incidence of the
tax has not been heavy. It offers, moreover, an opportunity for knowledge
by the Government of the general condition and business of all corporations,
and that means by far the most important part of the business of the country.
In the original act provision was made for the publication of returns.
This provision was subsequently amended by Congress, and the matter left
to the regulation of the President. I have directed the issue of the needed
regulations, and have made it possible for the public generally to know
from an examination of the record, the returns of all corporations, the
stock of which is listed on any public stock exchange or is offered for
sale to the general public by advertisement or otherwise. The returns of
those corporations whose stock is not so listed or offered for sale are
directed to be open to the inspection and examination of creditors and
stockholders of the corporation whose record is sought. The returns of
all corporations are subject to the inspection of any government officer
or to the examination of any court, in which the return made by the corporation
is relevant and competent evidence.
THE PAYNE TARIFF ACT.
The schedules of the rates of duty in the Payne tariff act have been
subjected to a great deal of criticism, some of it just, more of it unfounded,
and to much misrepresentation. The act was adopted in pursuance of a declaration
by the party which is responsible for it that a customs bill should be
a tariff for the protection of home industries, the measure of the protection
to be the difference between the cost of producing the imported article
abroad and the cost of producing it at home, together with such addition
to that difference as might give a reasonable profit to the home producer.
The chief criticism of this tariff is a charge that in respect to a number
of the schedules the declared measure was not followed, but a higher difference
retained or inserted by way of undue discrimination in favor of certain
industries and manufactures. Little, if any, of the criticism of the tariff
has been directed against the protective principle above stated.
The time in which the tariff was prepared undoubtedly was so short as
to make it impossible for the Congress and its experts to acquire all the
information necessary strictly to conform to the declared measure. In order
to avoid criticism of this kind in the future and for the .purpose of more
nearly conforming to the party promise, Congress at its last session made
provision at my request for the continuance of a board created under the
authority of the maximum and minimum clause of the tariff bill, and authorized
this board to expend the money appropriated under my direction for the
ascertainment of the cost of production at home and abroad of the various
articles included in the schedules of the tariff. The tariff board thus
appointed and authorized has been diligent in preparing itself for the
necessary investigations. The hope of those who have advocated the use
of this board for tariff purposes is that the question of the rate of a
duty imposed shall become more of a business question and less of a political
question, to be ascertained by experts of long training and accurate' knowledge.
The halt in business and the shock to business, due to the announcement
that a new tariff bill is to be prepared and put in operation, will be
avoided by treating the schedules one by one as occasion shall arise for
a change in the rates of each, and only after a report upon the schedule
by the tariff board competent to make such report. It is not likely that
the board will be able to make a report during the present session of Congress
on any of the schedules, because a proper examination involves an enormous
amount of detail and a great deal of care; but I hope to be able at the
opening of the new Congress, or at least during the session of that Congress,
to bring to its attention the facts in regard to those schedules in the
present tariff that may prove to need amendment. The carrying out of this
plan, of course, involves the full cooperation of Congress in limiting
the consideration in tariff matters to one schedule at a time, because
if a proposed amendment to a tariff bill is to involve a complete consideration
of all the schedules and another revision, then we shall only repeat the
evil from which the business of this country has in times past suffered
most grievously by stagnation and uncertainty, pending a resettlement of
a law affecting all business directly or indirectly. I can not too much
emphasize the importance and benefit of the plan above proposed for the
treatment of the tariff. It facilitates the removal of noteworthy defects
in an important law without a disturbance of business prosperity, which
is even more important to the happiness and the comfort of the people than
the elimination of instances of injustice in the tariff.
The inquiries which the members of the Tariff Board made during the
last summer into the methods pursued by other Governments with reference
to the fixing of tariffs and the determination of their effect upon trade,
show that each Government maintains an office or bureau, the officers and
employees of which have made their life work the study of tariff matters,
of foreign and home prices and cost of articles imported, and the effect
of the tariff upon trade, so that whenever a change is thought to be necessary
in the tariff law this office is the source of the most reliable information
as to the propriety of the change and its effect. I am strongly convinced
that we need in this Government just such an office, and that it can be
secured by making the Tariff Board already appointed a permanent tariff
commission, with such duties, powers, and emoluments as it may seem wise
to Congress to give. It has been proposed to enlarge the board from
three to five. The present number is convenient, but I do not know that
an increase of two members would be objectionable.
Whether or not the protective policy is to be continued, and the degree
of protection to be accorded to our home industries, are questions which
the people must decide through their chosen representatives; but whatever
policy is adopted, it is clear that the necessary legislation should be
based on an impartial, thorough, and continuous study of the facts.
BANKING AND CURRENCY REFORM.
The method of impartial scientific study by experts as a preliminary
to legislation, which I hope to see ultimately adopted as our fixed national
policy with respect to the tariff, rivers and harbors, waterways, and public
buildings, is also being pursued by the nonpartisan Monetary Commission
of Congress. An exhaustive and most valuable study of the banking and currency
systems of foreign countries has been completed.
A comparison of the business methods and institutions of our powerful
and successful commercial rivals with our own is sure to be of immense
value. I urge upon Congress the importance of a nonpartisan and disinterested
study and consideration of our banking and currency system. It is idle
to dream of commercial expansion, and of the development of our national
trade on a scale that measures up to our matchless opportunities, unless
we can lay a solid foundation in a sound and enduring banking and currency
system. The problem is not partisan, is not sectional--it is national.
The War Department has within its jurisdiction the management of the
Army, and, in connection therewith, the coast defenses; the government
of the dependencies of the Philippines and of Porto Rico; the recommendation
of plans for the improvement of harbors and waterways, and their execution
when adopted; and, by virtue of an executive order, the supervision of
the construction of the Panama Canal.
The Army of the United States is a small body compared with the total
number of people for the preservation of whose peace and good order it
is a last resource. The Army now numbers about 80,000 men, of whom about
18,000 are engaged in the Coast Artillery and detailed to the management
and use of the guns in the forts and batteries that protect our coasts.
The rest of the Army, or about 60,000, is the mobile part of our national
forces and is divided into 31 regiments of infantry, including the Porto
Rican regiment, 15 regiments of cavalry, 6 regiments of field artillery,
a corps of ordnance, of engineers, and of signal, a quartermaster's department,
a commissary department, and a medical corps.
The general plan for an army of the United States at peace should be
that of a skeleton organization with an excess of trained officers and
thus capable of rapid enlargement by enlistments, to be supplemented in
emergency by the national militia and a volunteer force. In some measure
this plan has been adopted in the very large proportion of cavalry and
field artillery as compared with infantry in the present army and on a
peace basis. An infantry force can be trained in six months; a cavalry
or a light artillery force not under one and one-half or two years; hence
the importance of having ready a larger number of the more skilled soldiers.
The militia system, for which Congress by the Constitution is authorized
to provide, was developed by the so-called Dick law, under which the discipline,
the tactics, the drill, the rank, the uniform, and the various branches
of the militia are assimilated as far as possible to those of the Regular
Army. Under the militia law, as the Constitution provides, the Governors
of the States appoint the militia officers, but, by appropriations from
Congress, States have been induced to comply with the rules of assimilation
between the Regular Army and the militia, so that now there is a force,
the efficiency of which differs in different States, which could be incorporated
under a single command with the Regular Army, and which for some time each
year receives the benefit of drill and maneuvers with conditions approximating
actual military service, under the supervision of Regular Army officers.
In the Army of the United States, in addition to the regular forces
and the militia forces which may be summoned to the defense of the Nation
by the President, there is also the volunteer force, which made up a very
large part of the army in the Civil War, and which in any war of long continuance
would become its most important constituent. There is an act which dates
from the Civil War, known as the Volunteer Act, which makes provision for
the enlistment of volunteers in the Army of the United States in time of
war. This was found to be so defective in the Philippine War that a special
act for the organization of volunteer regiments to take part in that war
was adopted, and it was much better adapted to the necessities of the case.
There is now pending in Congress a bill repealing the present Volunteer
Act and making provision for the organization of volunteer forces in time
of war, which is admirably adapted to meet the exigencies which would be
then presented. The passage of the bill would not entail a dollar's expense
upon the Government at this time, or in the future, until war comes, but
when war does come the methods therein directed are in accordance with
the best military judgment as to what they ought to be, and the act would
prevent the necessity for the discussion of new legislation and the delays
incident to its consideration and adoption. I earnestly urge the passage
of this Volunteer Bill.
I further recommend that Congress establish a commission to determine
as early as practicable a comprehensive policy for the organization, mobilization
and administration of the Regular Army, the organized militia, and the
volunteer forces in the event of war.
NEED FOR ADDITIONAL OFFICERS.
One of the great difficulties in the prompt organization and mobilization
of militia and volunteer forces is the absence of competent officers of
the rank of captain to teach the new army, by the unit of the company,
the business of being soldiers and of taking care of themselves so as to
render effective service. This need of army officers can only be supplied
by provisions of law authorizing the appointment of a greater number of
army officers than are needed to supply the commands of regular army troops
now enlisted in the service. There are enough regular army officers to
command the troops now enlisted, but Congress has authorized, and the Department
has followed the example of Congress and exercised the authority conferred
by detailing these army officers to duty other than that of the command
of troops. For instance, there are a large number of army officers assigned
to duty with military colleges or in colleges in which military training
is given. Then a large number of officers are assigned to General Staff
duty, and there are various other places to which army officers can be
and are legally assigned, which take them away from their regiments and
companies. In order that the militia of each State should be properly drilled
and made more like the regular army, regular army officers should be detailed
to assist the Adjutant-General of each State in the supervision of the
state militia; but this is impossible unless provision is made by Congress
for a very considerable increase in the number of company and field officers
of the Army. A bill is pending in Congress for this purpose, and I earnestly
hope that, in the interest of the proper development of a republican army,
an army, small in the time of peace but possible of prompt and adequate
enlargement in time of war, shall become possible under the laws of the
PROPOSED INCREASE IN ARMY ENGINEERS.
A bill, the strong argument for which can be based on the ground quite
similar to that of the increased officers bill, is a bill for the increase
of sixty in the Army Engineers. The Army Engineers are largely employed
in the expenditure of the moneys appropriated for the improvement of rivers
and harbors and in the construction of the Panama Canal. This, in addition
to their military duties, which include the building of fortifications
both on our coasts and in our dependencies, requires many more engineers
than the Army has, and public works, civil and military, are, therefore,
much delayed. I earnestly recommend the passage of this bill, which passed
the House at the last session and is now pending in the Senate.
I have directed that the estimates for appropriation for the improvement
of coast defenses in the United States should be reduced to a minimum,
while those for the completion of the needed fortifications at Corregidor
in the Philippine Islands and at Pearl Harbor in the Hawaiian Islands should
be expedited as much as possible. The proposition to make Olongapo and
Subig Bay the naval base for the Pacific was given up, and it is to be
treated merely as a supply station, while the fortifications in the Philippines
are to be largely confined to Corregidor Island and the adjacent islands
which command entrance to Manila Bay and which are being rendered impregnable
from land and sea attack. The Pacific Naval base has been transferred to
Pearl Harbor in the Hawaiian Islands. This necessitates the heavy fortification
of the harbor and the establishment of an important military station near
Honolulu. I urge that all the estimates made by the War Department for
these purposes be approved by Congressional appropriation.
During the last summer, at my request, the Secretary of War visited
the Philippine Islands and has described his trip in his report. He found
the Islands in a state of tranquillity and growing prosperity, due largely
to the change in the tariff laws, which has opened the markets of America
to the products of the Philippines, and has opened the Philippine markets
to American manufactures. The rapid increase in the trade between the two
countries is shown in the following table:
Philippine exports, fiscal years 1908-1910.
[Exclusive of gold and silver.] Fiscal Year To: United States
To: Other Countries Total
1908 $10,323,233 $22,493,334 $32,816,567
1909 10,215,331 20,778,232 30,993,563
1910 18,741,771 21,122,398 39,864,169
NOTE.--Latest monthly returns show exports for the year ending August,
1910, to the United States $20,035,902, or 49 per cent of the $41,075,738
total, against 031,275 to the United States, or 34 per cent of the $32,183,871
total for the year ending August, 1909.
Philippine imports, fiscal years 1908-1910.
[Exclusive of gold and silver and government supplies.] Fiscal Year
From: United States From: Other Countries Total
1908 $5,079,487 $25,838,870 $30,918,357
1909 4,691,770 23,100,270 27,792,397
1910 10,775,301 26,292,329 37,067,630
NOTE.--Latest monthly returns show imports for the year ending August,
1910, from the United States $11,615,982, or 30 per cent of the $39,025,667
total, against $5,193,419 from the United States, or 18 per cent of the
$28,948,011 total for the year ending August, 1909.
The year has been one of prosperity and progress in Porto Rico. Certain
political changes are embodied in the bill "To Provide a Civil Government
for Porto Rico and for other Purposes," which passed the House of Representatives
on June 15, 1910, at the last session of Congress, and is now awaiting
the action of the Senate.
The importance of those features of this bill relating to public health
and sanitation can not be overestimated.
The removal from politics of the judiciary by providing for the appointment
of the municipal judges is excellent, and I recommend that a step further
be taken by providing therein for the appointment of secretaries and marshals
of these courts.
The provision in the bill for a partially elective senate, the number
of elective members being progressively increased, is of doubtful wisdom,
and the composition of the senate as provided in the bill when introduced
in the House, seems better to meet conditions existing in Porto Rico. This
is an important measure, and I recommend its early consideration and passage.
RIVERS AND HARBORS.
I have already expressed my opinion to Congress in respect to the character
of the river and harbor bills which should be enacted into law; and I have
exercised as much power as I could under the law in directing the Chief
of Engineers to make his report to Congress conform to the needs of the
committee framing such a bill in determining which of the proposed improvements
is the more important and ought to be completed first, and promptly.
At the instance of Colonel Goethals, the Army Engineer officer in charge
of the work on the Panama Canal, I have just made a visit to the Isthmus
to inspect the work done and to consult with him on the ground as to certain
problems which are likely to arise in the near future. The progress of
the work is most satisfactory. If no unexpected obstacle presents itself,
the canal will be completed well within the time fixed by Colonel Goethals,
to wit, January 1, 1915, and within the estimate of cost, $375,000,000.
Press reports have reached the United States from time to time giving
accounts of slides of earth of very large yardage in the Culebra Cut and
elsewhere along the line, from which it might be inferred that the work
has been much retarded and that the time of completion has been necessarily
The report of Doctor Hayes, of the Geological Survey, whom I sent within
the last month to the Isthmus to make an investigation, shows that this
section of the Canal Zone is composed of sedimentary rocks of rather weak
structure and subject to almost immediate disintegration when exposed to
the air. Subsequent to the deposition of these sediments, igneous rocks,
harder and more durable, have been thrust into them, and being cold at
the time of their intrusion united but indifferently with the sedimentary
rock at the contacts. The result of these conditions is that as the cut
is deepened, causing unbalanced pressures, slides from the sides of the
cut have occurred. These are in part due to the flowing of surface soil
and decomposed sedimentary rocks upon inclined surfaces of the underlying
undecomposed rock and in part by the crushing of structurally weak beds
under excessive pressure. These slides occur on one side or the other of
the cut through a distance of 4 or 5 miles, and now that their character
is understood, allowance has been made in the calculations of yardage for
the amount of slides which will have to be removed and the greater slope
that will have to be given to the bank in many places in order to prevent
their recurrence. Such allowance does not exceed ten millions of yards.
Considering that the number of yards removed from this cut on an average
of each month through the year is 1,300,000, and that the total remaining
to be excavated, including slides, is about 30,000,000 yards, it is seen
that this addition to the excavation does not offer any great reason for
While this feature of the material to be excavated in the cut will not
seriously delay or obstruct the construction of a canal of the lock type,
the increase of excavation due to such slides in the cut made 85 feet deeper
for a sea-level canal would certainly have been so great as to delay its
completion to a time beyond the patience of the American people.
FORTIFY THE CANAL.
Among questions arising for present solution is whether the Canal shall
be fortified. I have already stated to the Congress that I strongly favor
fortification and I now reiterate this opinion and ask your consideration
of the subject in the light of the report already before you made by a
If, in our discretion, we believe modern fortifications to be necessary
to the adequate protection and policing of the Canal, then it is our duty
to construct them. We have built the Canal. It is our property. By convention
we have indicated our desire for, and indeed undertaken, its universal
and equal use. It is also well known that one of the chief objects in the
construction of the Canal has been to increase the military effectiveness
of our Navy.
Failure to fortify the Canal would make the attainment of both these
aims depend upon the mere moral obligations of the whole international
public--obligations which we would be powerless to enforce and which could
never in any other way be absolutely safeguarded against a desperate and
Another question which arises for consideration and possible legislation
is the question of tolls in the Canal. This question is necessarily affected
by the probable tonnage which will go through the Canal. It is all a matter
of estimate, but one of the government commission in 1900 investigated
the question and made a report. He concluded that the total tonnage of
the vessels employed in commerce that could use the Isthmian Canal in 1914
would amount to 6,843,805 tons net register, and that this traffic would
increase 25.1 per cent per decade; that it was not probable that all the
commerce included in the totals would at once abandon the routes at present
followed and make use of the new Canal, and that it might take some time,
perhaps two years, to readjust trade with reference to the new conditions
which the Canal would establish. He did not include, moreover, the tonnage
of war vessels, although it is to be inferred that such vessels would make
considerable use of the Canal. In the matter of tolls he reached the conclusion
that a dollar a net ton would not drive business away from the Canal, but
that a higher rate would do so.
In determining what the tolls should be we certainly ought not to insist
that they should at once amount to enough to pay the interest on the investment
of $400,000,000 which the United States has made in the construction of
the Canal. We ought not to do this, first, because the benefit to be derived
by the United States from this expenditure is not to be measured solely
by a return upon the investment. If it were, then the construction might
well have been left to private enterprise. It was because an adequate return
upon the money invested could not be expected immediately, or in the near
future, and because there were peculiar political advantages to be derived
from the construction of the Canal that it fell to the Government to advance
the money and perform the work.
In addition to the benefit to our naval strength, the Canal greatly
increases the trade facilities of the United States. It will undoubtedly
cheapen the rates of transportation in all freight between the Eastern
and Western seaboard. Then, if we are to have a world canal, and if we
are anxious that the world's trade shall use it, we must recognize that
we have an active competitor in the Suez Canal and that there are other
means of carriage between the two oceans--by the Tehuantepec Railroad and
by other railroads and freight routes in Central America.
In all these cases the question whether the Panama Canal is to be used
and its tonnage increased will be determined mainly by the charge for its
use. My own impression is that the tolls ought not to exceed $1 per net
ton. On January 1, 1911, the tolls in the Suez Canal are to be 7 francs
and 25 centimes for I net ton by Suez Canal measurement, which is a modification
of Danube measurement A dollar a ton will secure under the figures above
a gross income from the Panama Canal of nearly $7,000,000. The cost of
maintenance and operation is estimated to exceed $3,000,000. Ultimately,
of course, with the normal increase in trade, we hope the income will approximate
the interest charges upon the investment. The inquiries already made of
the Chief Engineer of the Canal show that the present consideration of
this question is necessary in order that the commerce of the world may
have time to adjust itself to the new conditions resulting from the opening
of this new highway. On the whole I should recommend that within certain
limits the President be authorized to fix the tolls of the Canal and adjust
them to what seems to be commercial necessity.
MAINTENANCE OF CANAL.
The next question that arises is as to the maintenance, management,
and general control of the canal after its completion. It should be premised
that it is an essential part of our navy establishment to have the coal,
oil and other ship supplies, a dry dock, and repair shops, conveniently
located with reference to naval vessels passing through the canal. Now,
if the Government, for naval purposes, is to undertake to furnish these
conveniences to the navy, and they are conveniences equally required by
commercial vessels, there would seem to be strong reasons why the Government
should take over and include in its management the furnishing, not only
to the navy but to the public, dry-dock and repair-shop facilities, and
the sale of coal, oil, and other ship supplies.
The maintenance of a lock canal of this enormous size in a sparsely
populated country and in the tropics, where the danger from disease is
always present, requires a large and complete and well-trained organization
with full police powers, exercising the utmost care. The visitor to the
canal who is impressed with the wonderful freedom from tropical diseases
on the Isthmus must not be misled as to the constant vigilance that is
needed to preserve this condition. The vast machinery of the locks, the
necessary amount of dredging, the preservation of the banks of the canal
from slides, the operation and the maintenance of the equipment of the
railway--will all require a force, not, of course, to be likened in any
way to the present organization for construction, but a skilled body of
men who can keep in a state of usefulness this great instrument of commerce.
Such an organization makes it easy to include within its functions the
furnishing of dry-dock, fuel, repairs and supply facilities to the trade
of the world. These will be more essential at the Isthmus of Panama than
they are at Port Said or Suez, because there are no depots for coal, supplies,
and other commercial necessities within thousands of miles of the Isthmus.
Another important reason why these ancillary duties may well be undertaken
by the Government is the opportunity for discrimination between patrons
of the canal that is offered where private concessions are granted for
the furnishing of these facilities. Nothing would create greater prejudice
against the canal than the suspicion that certain lines of traffic were
favored in the furnishing of supplies or that the supplies were controlled
by any large interest that might have a motive for increasing the cost
of the use of the canal. It may be added that the termini are not ample
enough to permit the fullest competition in respect to the furnishing of
these facilities and necessities to the world's trade even if it were wise
to invite such competition and the granting of the concession would necessarily,
under these circumstances, take on the appearance of privilege or monopoly.
PROHIBITION OF RAILROAD OWNERSHIP OF CANAL STEAMERS.
I can not close this reference to the canal without suggesting as a
wise amendment to the interstate commerce law a provision prohibiting interstate
commerce railroads from owning or controlling ships engaged in the trade
through the Panama Canal. I believe such a provision may be needed to save
to the people of the United States the benefits of the competition in trade
between the eastern and western seaboards which this canal was constructed
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE.
The duties of the Department of Justice have been greatly increased
by legislation of Congress enacted in the interest of the general welfare
of the people and extending its activities into avenues plainly within
its constitutional jurisdiction, but which it has not been thought wise
or necessary for the General Government heretofore to occupy.
I am glad to say that under the appropriations made for the Department,
the Attorney-General has so improved its organization that a vast amount
of litigation of a civil and criminal character has been disposed of during
the current year. This will explain the necessity for slightly increasing
the estimates for the expenses of the Department. His report shows the
recoveries made on behalf of the Government, of duties fraudulently withheld,
public lands improperly patented, fines and penalties for trespass, prosecutions
and convictions under the antitrust law, and prosecutions under the interstate-commerce
law. I invite especial attention to the prosecutions under the Federal
law of the so-called "bucket shops," and of those schemes to defraud in
which the use of the mail is an essential part of the fraudulent conspiracy,
prosecutions which have saved ignorant and weak members of the public and
are saving them hundreds of millions of dollars. The violations of the
antitrust law present perhaps the most important litigation before the
Department, and the number of cases filed shows the activity of the Government
in enforcing that statute.
In a special message last year I brought to the attention of Congress
the propriety and wisdom of enacting a general law providing for the incorporation
of industrial and other companies engaged in interstate commerce, and I
renew my recommendation in that behalf.
PAYMENT OF JUST CLAIMS.
I invite the attention of Congress to the great number of claims which,
at the instance of Congress, have been considered by the Court of Claims
and decided to be valid claims against the Government. The delay that occurs
in the payment of the money due under the claims injures the reputation
of the Government as an honest debtor, and I earnestly recommend that those
claims which come to Congress with the judgment and approval of the Court
of Claims should be promptly paid.
REFORM IN JUDICIAL PROCEDURE.
One great crying need in the United States is cheapening the cost of
litigation by simplifying judicial procedure and expediting final judgment.
Under present conditions the poor man is at a woeful disadavantage in a
legal contest with a corporation or a rich opponent. The necessity for
the reform exists both in the United States courts and in all State courts.
In order to bring it about, however, it naturally falls to the General
Government by its example to furnish a model to all States. A legislative
commission appointed by joint resolution of Congress to revise the procedure
in the United States courts has as yet made no report.
Under the law the Supreme Court of the United States has the power and
is given the duty to frame the equity rules of procedure which are to obtain
in the Federal courts of first instance. In view of the heavy burden of
pressing litigation which that Court has had to carry, with one or two
of its members incapacitated through ill health, it has not been able to
take up problems of improving the equity procedure, which has practically
remained the same since the organization of the Court in 1789. It is reasonable
to expect that with all the vacancies upon the Court filled, it will take
up the question of cheapening and simplifying the procedure in equity in
the courts of the United States. The equity business is much the more important
in the Federal courts, and I may add much the more expensive. I am strongly
convinced that the best method of improving judicial procedure at law is
to empower the Supreme Court to do it through the medium of the rules of
the court, as in equity. This is the way in which it has been done in England,
and thoroughly done. The simplicity and expedition of procedure in the
English courts today make a model for the reform of other systems.
Several of the Lord Chancellors of England and of the Chief Justices
have left their lasting impress upon the history of their country by their
constructive ability in proposing and securing the passage of remedial
legislation effecting law reforms. I can not conceive any higher duty that
the Supreme Court could perform than in leading the way to a simplification
of procedure in the United States courts.
RELIEF OF SUPREME COURT FROM UNNECESSARY APPEALS.
No man ought to have, as a matter of right, a review of his case by
the Supreme Court. He should be satisfied by one hearing before a court
of first instance and one review by a court of appeals. The proper and
chief usefulness of a Supreme Court, and especially of the Supreme Court
of the United States, is, in the cases which come before it, so to expound
the law, and especially the fundamental law -- the Constitution -- as to
furnish precedents for the inferior courts in future litigation and for
the executive officers in the construction of statutes and the performance
of their legal duties. Therefore, any provisions for review of cases by
the Supreme Court that cast upon that Court the duty of passing on questions
of evidence and the construction of particular forms of instruments, like
indictments, or wills, or contracts, decisions not of general application
or importance, merely clog and burden the Court and render more difficult
its higher function, which makes it so important a part of the framework
of our Government. The Supreme Court is now carrying an unnecessary burden
of appeals of this kind, and I earnestly urge that it be removed.
The statutes respecting the review by the Supreme Court of the United
States of decisions of the Court of Appeals of the District of Columbia
ought to be so amended as to place that court in the same position with
respect to the review of its decisions as that of the various United States
Circuit Courts of Appeals. The act of March 2, 1907, authorizing appeals
by the Government from certain judgments in criminal cases where the defendant
has not been put in jeopardy, within the meaning of the Constitution, should
be amended so that such appeals should be taken to the Circuit Courts of
Appeals instead of to the Supreme Court in all cases except those involving
the construction of the Constitution or the constitutionality of a statute,
with the same power in the Supreme Court to review on certiorari as is
now exercised by that court over determinations of the several Circuit
Courts of Appeals. Appeals in copyright cases should reach final judgment
in the courts of appeals instead of the Supreme Court as now. The decision
of the courts of appeals should be made final also in all cases wherein
jurisdiction rests on both diverse citizenship and the existence of a federal
question, and not as now be reviewable in the Supreme Court when the case
involves more than one thousand dollars. Appeals from the United States
Court in Porto Rico should run to the Circuit Court of Appeals of the third
circuit instead of to the Supreme Court. These suggested changes would,
I am advised, relieve the Supreme Court of the consideration of about 100
The American Bar Association has had before it the question of reducing
the burden of litigation involved in reversals on review and new trials
or re-hearings and in frivolous appeals in habeas corpus and criminal cases.
Their recommendations have been embodied in bills now pending in Congress.
The recommendations are not radical, but they will accomplish much if adopted
into law, and I earnestly recommend the passage of the bills embodying
I wish to renew my urgent recommendation made in my last Annual Message
in favor of the passage of a law which shall regulate the issuing of injunctions
in equity without notice in accordance with the best practice now in vogue
in the courts of the United States. I regard this of especial importance,
first because it has been promised, and second because it will deprive
those who now complain of certain alleged abuses in the improper issuing
of injunctions without notice of any real ground for further amendment
and will take away all semblance of support for the extremely radical legislation
they propose, which will be most pernicious if adopted, will sap the foundations
of judicial power, and legalize that cruel social instrument, the secondary
I further recommend to Congress the passage of the bill now pending
for the increase in the salaries of the Federal Judges, by which the Chief
Justice of the United States shall receive $17,500 and the Associate Justices
of the Supreme Court $17,000; the Circuit Judges constituting the Circuit
Court of Appeals shall receive $10,000, and the District Judges $9,000.
These judges exercise a wise jurisdiction and their duties require of them
a profound knowledge of the law, great ability in the dispatch of business,
and care and delicacy in the exercise of their jurisdiction so as to avoid
conflict whenever possible between the Federal and the State courts. The
positions they occupy ought to be filled by men who have shown the greatest
ability in their professional work at the bar, and it is the poorest economy
possible for the Government to pay salaries so low for judicial service
as not to be able to command the best talent of the legal profession in
every part of the country. The cost of living is such, especially in the
large cities, that even the salaries fixed in the proposed bill will enable
the incumbents to accumulate little, if anything, to support their families
after their death. Nothing is so important to the preservation of our country
and its beloved institutions as the maintenance of the independence of
the judiciary, and next to the life tenure an adequate salary is the most
material contribution to the maintenance of independence on the part of
POSTAL SAVINGS BANKS.
At its last session Congress made provision for the establishment of
savings banks by the Post-Office Department of this Government, by which,
under the general control of trustees, consisting of the Postmaster-General,
the Secretary of the Treasury and the Attorney-General, the system could
be begun in a few cities and towns, and enlarged to cover within its operations
as many cities and towns and as large a part of the country as seemed wise.
The initiation and establishment of such a system has required a great
deal of study on the part of the experts in the Post-Office and Treasury
Departments, but a system has now been devised which is believed to be
more economical and simpler in its operation than any similar system abroad.
Arrangements have been perfected so that savings banks will be opened in
some cities and towns on the 1st of January, and there will be a gradual
extension of the benefits of the plan to the rest of the country.
WIPING OUT OF POSTAL DEFICIT.
As I have said, the Post-Office Department is a great business department,
and I am glad to note the fact that under its present management principles
of business economy and efficiency are being applied. For many years there
has been a deficit in the operations of the Post-Office Department which
has been met by appropriation from the Treasury. The appropriation estimated
for last year from the Treasury over and above the receipts of the Department
was $17,500,000. I am glad to record the fact that of that $17,500,000
estimated for, $11,500,000 were saved and returned to the Treasury. The
personal efforts of the Postmaster-General secured the effective cooperation
of the thousands of postmasters and other postal officers throughout the
country in carrying out his plans of reorganization and retrenchment. The
result is that the Postmaster-General has been able to make his estimate
of expenses for the present year so low as to keep within the amount the
postal service is expected to earn. It is gratifying to report that the
reduction in the deficit has been accomplished without any curtailment
of postal facilities. On the contrary the service has been greatly extended
during the year in all its branches. A principle which the Postmaster-General
has recommended and sought to have enforced in respect to all appointments
has been that those appointees who have rendered good service should be
reappointed. This has greatly strengthened the interest of postmasters
throughout the country in maintaining efficiency and economy in their offices,
because they believed generally that this would secure for them a further
EXTENSION OF THE CLASSIFIED SERVICE.
Upon the recommendation of the Postmaster-General, I have included in
the classified service all assistant postmasters, and I believe that this
giving a secure tenure to those who are the most important subordinates
of Postmasters will add much to the efficiency of their offices and an
economical administration. A large number of the fourth-class postmasters
are now in the classified service. I think it would be wise to put in the
classified service the first, second, and third class postmasters. It is
more logical to do this than to classify the fourth-class postmasters,
for the reason that the fourth-class post-offices are invariably small,
and the postmasters are necessarily men who must combine some other business
with the postmastership, whereas the first, second, and third class postmasters
are paid a sufficient amount to justify the requirement that they shall
have no other business and that they shall devote their attention to their
post-office duties. To classify first, second, and third class postmasters
would require the passage of an act changing the method of their appointment
so as to take away the necessity for the advice and consent of the Senate.
I am aware that this is inviting from the Senate a concession in respect
to its quasi executive power that is considerable, but I believe it to
be in the interest of good administration and efficiency of service. To
make this change would take the postmasters out of politics; would relieve
Congressmen who now are burdened with the necessity of making recommendations
for these places of a responsibility that must be irksome and can create
nothing but trouble; and it would result in securing from postmasters greater
attention to business, greater fidelity, and consequently greater economy
and efficiency in the post-offices which they conduct.
THE FRANKING PRIVILEGE.
The unrestricted manner in which the franking privilege is now being
used by the several branches of the Federal service and by Congress has
laid it open to serious abuses, a fact clearly established through investigations
recently instituted by the Department. While it has been impossible without
a better control of franking to determine the exact expense to the Government
of this practice, there can be no doubt that it annually reaches into the
millions. It is believed that many abuses of the franking system could
be prevented, and consequently a marked economy effected, by supplying
through the agencies of the postal service special official envelopes and
stamps for the free mail of the Government, all such envelopes and stamps
to be issued on requisition to the various branches of the Federal service
requiring them, and such records to be kept of all official stamp supplies
as will enable the Post-Office Department to maintain a proper postage
account covering the entire volume of free Government mail. As the first
step in the direction of this reform, special stamps and stamped envelopes
have been provided for use instead of franks in the free transmission of
the official mail resulting from the business of the new postal savings
system. By properly recording the issuance of such stamps and envelopes
accurate records can be kept of the cost to the Government of handling
the postal savings mail, which is certain to become an important item of
expense and one that should be separately determined. In keeping with this
plan it is hoped that Congress will authorize the substitution of special
official stamps and stamped envelopes for the various forms of franks now
used to carry free of postage the vast volume of Departmental and Congressional
mail matter. During the past year methods of accounting similar to those
employed in the most progressive of our business establishments have been
introduced in the postal service and nothing has so impeded the Department's
plan in this regard as the impossibility of determining with any exactness
how far the various expenses of the postal service are increased by the
present unrestricted use of the franking privilege. It is believed that
the adoption of a more exact method of dealing with this problem as proposed
will prove to be of tremendous advantage in the work of placing the postal
service on a strictly businesslike basis.
SECOND-CLASS MAIL MATTER.
In my last Annual Message I invited the attention of Congress to the
inadequacy of the postal rate imposed upon second-class mail matter in
so far as that includes magazines, and showed by figures prepared by experts
of the Post-Office Department that the Government was rendering a service
to the magazines, costing many millions in excess of the compensation paid.
An answer was attempted to this by the representatives of the magazines,
and a reply was filed to this answer by the Post-Office Department. The
utter inadequacy of the answer, considered in the light of the reply of
the Post-Office Department, I think must appeal to any fair-minded person.
Whether the answer was all that could be said in behalf of the magazines
is another question. I agree that the question is one of fact; but I insist
that if the fact is as the experts of the Post-Office Department show,
that we are furnishing to the owners of magazines a service worth millions
more than they pay for it, then justice requires that the rate should be
increased. The increase in the receipts of the Department resulting from
this change may be devoted to increasing the usefulness of the Department
in establishing a parcels post and in reducing the cost of first-class
postage to one cent. It has been said by the Postmaster-General that a
fair adjustment might be made under which the advertising part of the magazine
should be charged for at a different and higher rate from that of the reading
matter. This would relieve many useful magazines that are not circulated
at a profit, and would not shut them out from the use of the mails by a
With respect to the parcels post, I respectfully recommend its adoption
on all rural-delivery routes, and that 11 pounds--the international limit--be
made the limit of carriage in such post, and this, with a view to its general
extension when the income of the Post-Office will permit it and the Postal
Savings Banks shall have been fully established. The same argument is made
against the parcels post that was made against the postal savings bank--that
it is introducing the Government into a business which ought to be conducted
by private persons, and is paternalism. The Post-Office Department has
a great plant and a great organization, reaching into the most remote hamlet
of the United States, and with this machinery it is able to do a great
many things economically that if a new organization were necessary it would
be impossible to do without extravagant expenditure. That is the reason
why the postal savings bank can be carried on at a small additional cost,
and why it is possible to incorporate at a very inconsiderable expense
a parcels post in the rural-delivery system. A general parcels post will
involve a much greater outlay.
In the last annual report of the Secretary of the Navy and in my Annual
Message, attention was called to the new detail of officers in the Navy
Department by which officers of flag rank were assigned to duty as Aides
to the Secretary in respect to naval operations, personnel, inspection,
and material. This change was a substantial compliance with the recommendation
of the Commission on Naval Reorganization, headed by Mr. Justice Moody,
and submitted to President Roosevelt on February 26, 1909. Through the
advice of this committee of line officers, the Secretary is able to bring
about a proper coordination of all the branches of the naval department
with greater military efficiency. The Secretary of the Navy recommends
that this new organization be recognized by legislation and thus made permanent.
I concur in the recommendation.
The Secretary, in view of the conclusions of a recent Court of Inquiry
on certain phases of Marine Corps administration, recommends that the Major-General
Commandant of the Marine Corps be appointed for a four years' term, and
that officers of the Adjutant and Inspector's department be detailed from
the line. He also asks for legislation to improve the conditions now existing
in the personnel of officers of the Navy, particularly with regard to the
age and experience of flag officers and captains, and points out that it
is essential to the highest efficiency of the Navy that the age of our
officers be reduced and that flag officers, particularly, should gain proper
experience as flag officers, in order to enable them to properly command
fleets. I concur in the Secretary's recommendations.
COVERING OF NAVAL SUPPLY FUND INTO TREASURY.
I commend to your attention the report of the Secretary on the change
in the system of cost accounting in navy-yards, and also to the history
of the naval supply fund and the present conditions existing in regard
to that matter. Under previous practice and what now seems to have been
an erroneous construction of the law, the supply fund of the navy was increased
from $2,700,000 to something over $14,000,000, and a system of accounting
was introduced which prevented the striking of a proper balance and a knowledge
of the exact cost of maintaining the naval establishment. The system has
now been abandoned and a Naval Supply Account established by law July 1,
1910. The Naval Supply fund of $2,700,000 is now on deposit in the Treasury
to the credit of the Department. The Secretary recommends that the Naval
Supply Account be made permanent by law and that the $2,700,000 of the
naval supply fund be covered into the Treasury as unnecessary, and I ask
for legislative authority to do this. This sum when covered into the Treasury
will be really a reduction in the recorded Naval cost for this year.
ESTIMATES AND BUILDING PROGRAM.
The estimates of the Navy Department are $5,000,000 less than the appropriations
for the same purpose last year, and included in this is the building program
of the same amount as that submitted for your consideration last year.
It is merely carrying out the plan of building two battleships a year,
with a few needed auxiliary vessels. I earnestly hope that this program
will be adopted.
ABOLITION OF NAVY-YARDS.
The Secretary of the Navy has given personal examination to every navy-yard
and has studied the uses of the navy-yards with reference to the necessities
of our fleet. With a fleet considerably less than half the size of that
of the British navy, we have shipyards more than double the number, and
there are several of these shipyards, expensively equipped with modern
machinery, which after investigation the Secretary of the Navy believes
to be entirely useless for naval purposes. He asks authority to abandon
certain of them and to move their machinery to other places where it can
be made of use.
In making these recommendations the Secretary is following directly
along progressive lines which have been adopted in our great commercial
and manufacturing consolidations in this country; that is, of dismantling
unnecessary and inadequate plants and discontinuing their existence where
it has been demonstrated that it is unprofitable to continue their maintenance
at an expense not commensurate to their product.
GUANTANAMO PROPER NAVAL BASE.
The Secretary points out that the most important naval base in the West
Indies is Guantanamo, in the southeastern part of Cuba. Its geographical
situation is admirably adapted to protect the commercial paths to the Panama
Canal, and he shows that by the expenditure of less than half a million
dollars, with the machinery which he shall take from other navy-yards,
he can create a naval station at Guantanamo of sufficient size and equipment
to serve the purpose of an emergency naval base. I earnestly join in the
recommendation that he be given the authority which he asks. I am quite
aware that such action is likely to arouse local opposition; but I conceive
it to be axiomatic that in legislating in the interest of the Navy, and
for the general protection of the country by the Navy, mere local pride
or pecuniary interest in the establishment of a navy-yard or station ought
to play no part. The recommendation of the Secretary is based upon the
judgment of impartial naval officers, entirely uninfluenced by any geographical
or sectional considerations.
JOHN PAUL JONES.
I unite with the Secretary in the recommendation that an appropriation
be made to construct a suitable crypt at Annapolis for the custody of the
remains of John Paul Jones.
The complete success of our country in Arctic exploration should not
remain unnoticed. For centuries there has been friendly rivalry in this
field of effort between the foremost nations and between the bravest and
most accomplished men. Expeditions to the unknown North have been encouraged
by enlightened governments and deserved honors have been granted to the
daring men who have conducted them. The unparalleled accomplishment of
an American in reaching the North Pole, April 6, 1909, approved by critical
examination of the most expert scientists, has added to the distinction
of our navy, to which he belongs, and reflects credit upon his country.
His unique success has received generous acknowledgment from scientific
bodies and institutions of learning in Europe and America. I recommend
fitting recognition by Congress of the great achievement of Robert Edwin
DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR.
APPEALS TO COURT IN LAND CASES.
The Secretary of the Interior recommends a change of the law in respect
to the procedure in adjudicating claims for lands, by which appeals can
be taken from the decisions of the Department to the Court of Appeals of
the District of Columbia for a judicial consideration of the rights of
the claimant. This change finds complete analogy in the present provision
for appeals from the decisions of the Commissioner of Patents. The judgments
of the court in such cases would be of decisive value to land claimants
generally and to the Department of the Interior in the administration of
the law, would enable claimants to bring into Court the final consideration
of issues as to the title to Government land and would, I think, obviate
a good deal of the subsequent litigation that now arises in our Western
courts. The bill is pending, I believe, in the House, having been favorably
reported from the Committee on Public Lands, and I recommend its enactment.
ARREARS WIPED OUT.
One of the difficulties in the Interior Department and in the Land Office
has been the delays attendant upon the consideration by the Land Office
and the Secretary of the Interior of claims for patents of public lands
to individuals. I am glad to say that under the recent appropriations of
the Congress and the earnest efforts of the Secretary and his subordinates,
these arrears have been disposed of, and the work of the Department has
been brought more nearly up to date in respect to the pending business
than ever before in its history. Economies have been effected where possible
without legislative assistance, and these are shown in the reduced estimates
for the expenses of the Department during the current fiscal year and during
the year to come.
The subject of the conservation of the public domain has commanded the
attention of the people within the last two or three years.
There is no need for radical reform in the methods of disposing of what
are really agricultural lands. The present laws have worked well. The enlarged
homestead law has encouraged the successful farming of lands in the semiarid
The total sum already accumulated in the fund provided by the act for
the reclamation of arid lands is about $69,449,058.76, and of this, all
but $6,241,058.76 has been allotted to the various projects, of which there
are thirty. Congress at its last session provided for the issuing of certificates
of indebtedness not exceeding twenty millions of dollars, to be redeemed
from the reclamation fund when the proceeds of lands sold and from the
water-rents should be sufficient. Meantime, in accordance with the provisions
of the law, I appointed a board of army engineers to examine the projects
and to ascertain which are feasible and worthy of completion. That board
has made a report upon the subject, which I shall transmit in a separate
message within a few days.
In September last conservation Congress was held at St. Paul, at which
I delivered an address on the subject of conservation so far as it was
within the jurisdiction and possible action of the Federal Government.
In that address I assembled from the official records the statistics and
facts as to what had been done in this behalf in the administration of
my predecessor and in my own, and indicated the legislative measures which
I believed to be wise in order to secure the best use, in the public interest,
of what remains of our National domain. There was in this address a very
full discussion of the reasons which led me to the conclusions stated.
For the purpose of saving in an official record a comprehensive resume
of the statistics and facts gathered with some difficulty in that address,
and to avoid their repetition in the body of this message, I venture to
make the address an accompanying appendix. The statistics are corrected
to November 15th last.
For the reasons stated in the conservation address, I recommend:
First, that the limitation now imposed upon the Executive which forbids
his reserving more forest lands in Oregon, Washington, Idaho, Montana,
Colorado, and Wyoming, be repealed.
Second, that the coal deposits of the Government be leased after advertisement
inviting competitive bids, for terms not exceeding fifty years, with a
minimum rental and royalties upon the coal mined, to be readjusted every
ten or twelve years, and with conditions as to maintenance which will secure
proper mining, and as to assignment which will prevent combinations to
monopolize control of the coal in any one district or market. I do not
think that coal measures under 2,500 acres of surface would be too large
an amount to lease to any one lessee.
The Secretary of the Interior thinks there are difficulties in the way
of leasing public coal lands, which objections he has set forth in his
report, the force of which I freely concede. I entirely approved his stating
at length in his report the objections in order that the whole subject
may be presented to Congress, but after a full consideration I favor a
leasing system and recommend it.
Third, that the law should provide the same separation in respect to
government phosphate lands of surface and mineral rights that now obtains
in coal lands and that power to lease such lands upon terms and limitations
similar to those above recommended for coal leases, with an added condition
enabling the Government to regulate, and if need be to prohibit, the export
to foreign countries of the product.
Fourth, that the law should allow a prospector for oil or gas to have
the right to prospect for two years over a certain tract of government
land, the right to be evidenced by a license for which he shall pay a small
sum; and that upon discovery, a lease may be granted upon terms securing
a minimum rental and proper royalties to the Government, and also the conduct
of the oil or gas well in accord with the best method for husbanding the
supply of oil in the district. The period of the leases should not be as
long as those of coal, but they should contain similar provisions as to
assignment to prevent monopolistic combinations.
Fifth, that water-power sites be directly leased by the Federal Government,
after advertisement and bidding, for not exceeding fifty years upon a proper
rental and with a condition fixing rates charged to the public for units
of electric power, both rental and rates to be readjusted equitably every
ten years by arbitration or otherwise, with suitable provisions against
assignment to prevent monopolistic combinations. Or, that the law shall
provide that upon application made by the authorities of the State where
the water-power site is situated, it may be patented to the State on condition
that the State shall dispose of it under terms like those just described,
and shall enforce those terms, or upon failure to comply with the condition
the water-power site and all the plant and improvement on the site shall
be forfeited and revert to the United States, the President being given
the power to declare the forfeiture and to direct legal proceedings for
its enforcement. Either of these methods would, I think, accomplish the
proper public purpose in respect to water-power sites, but one or the other
should be promptly adopted.
NECESSITY FOR PROMPT ACTION.
I earnestly urge upon Congress that at this session general conservation
legislation of the character indicated be adopted. At its last session
this Congress took most useful and proper steps in the cause of conservation
by allowing the Executive, through withdrawals, to suspend the action of
the existing laws in respect to much of the public domain. I have not thought
that the danger of disposing of coal lands in the United States under the
present laws in large quantities was so great as to call for their withdrawal,
because under the present provisions it is reasonably certain that the
Government will receive the real value of the land. But, in respect to
oil lands, or phosphate lands, and of gas lands in the United States, and
in respect to coal lands in Alaska, I have exercised the full power of
withdrawal with the hope that the action of Congress would follow promptly
and prevent that tying up of the resources of the country in the western
and less settled portion and in Alaska, which means stagnation and retrogression.
The question of conservation is not a partisan one, and I sincerely
hope that even in the short time of the present session consideration may
be given to those questions which have now been much discussed, and that
action may be taken upon them.
With reference to the government of Alaska, I have nothing to add to
the recommendations I made in my last message on the subject. I am convinced
that the migratory character of the population, its unequal distribution,
and its smallness of number, which the new census shows to be about 50,000,
in relation to the enormous expanse of the territory, make it altogether
impracticable to give to those people who are in Alaska to-day and may
not be there a year hence, the power to elect a legislature to govern an
immense territory to which they have a relation so little permanent. It
is far better for the development of the territory that it be committed
to a commission to be appointed by the Executive, with limited legislative
powers sufficiently broad to meet the local needs, than to continue the
present insufficient government with few remedial powers, or to make a
popular government where there is not proper foundation upon which to rest
The suggestion that the appointment of a commission will lead to the
control of the government by corporate or selfish and exploiting interests
has not the slightest foundation in fact. Such a government worked well
in the Philippines, and would work well in Alaska, and those who are really
interested in the proper development of that territory for the benefit
of the people who live in it and the benefit of the people of the United
States, who own it, should support the institution of such a government.
I have been asked to recommend that the credit of the Government be
extended to aid the construction of railroads in Alaska. I am not ready
now to do so. A great many millions of dollars have already been expended
in the construction of at least two railroads, and if laws be passed providing
for the proper development of the resources of Alaska, especially for the
opening up of the coal lands, I believe that the capital already invested
will induce the investment of more capital, sufficient to complete the
railroads building, and to furnish cheap coal not only to Alaska but to
the whole Pacific coast. The passage of a law permitting the leasing of
government coal lands in Alaska after public competition, and the appointment
of a commission for the government of the territory, with enabling powers
to meet the local needs, will lead to an improvement in Alaska and the
development of her resources that is likely to surprise the country.
Our national parks have become so extensive and involve so much detail
of action in their control that it seems to me there ought to be legislation
creating a bureau for their care and control. The greatest natural wonder
of this country and the surrounding territory should be included in another
national park. I refer to the Grand Canyon of the Colorado.
The uniform policy of the Government in the matter of granting pensions
to those gallant and devoted men who fought to save the life of the Nation
in the perilous days of the great Civil War, has always been of the most
liberal character. Those men are now rapidly passing away. The best obtainable
official statistics show that they are dying at the rate of something over
three thousand a month, and, in view of their advancing years, this rate
must inevitably, in proportion, rapidly increase. To the man who risked
everything on the field of battle to save the Nation in the hour of its
direst need, we owe a debt which has not been and should not be computed
in a begrudging or parsimonious spirit. But while we should be actuated
by this spirit to the soldier himself, care should be exercised not to
go to absurd lengths, or distribute the bounty of the Government to classes
of persons who may, at this late day, from a mere mercenary motive, seek
to obtain some legal relation with an old veteran now tottering on the
brink of the grave. The true spirit of the pension laws is to be found
in the noble sentiments expressed by Mr. Lincoln in his last inaugural
address, wherein, in speaking of the Nation's duty to its soldiers when
the struggle should be over, he said we should "care for him who shall
have borne the battle, and for his widow and orphans."
DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE.
VALUE OF THIS YEAR'S CROPS.
The report of the Secretary of Agriculture invites attention to the
stupendous value of the agricultural products of this country, amounting
in all to $8,926,000,000 for this year. This amount is larger than that
of 1909 by $305,000,000. The existence of such a crop indicates a good
prospect for business throughout the country. A notable change for the
better is commented upon by the Secretary in the fact that the South, especially
in those regions where the boll weevil has interfered with the growth of
cotton, has given more attention to the cultivation of corn and other cereals,
so that there is a greater diversification of crops in the South than ever
before--and all to the great advantage of that section.
The report contains a most interesting account of the activities of
the Department in its various bureaus, showing how closely the agricultural
progress in this country is following along the lines of improvement recommended
by the Department through its publications and the results of its experiment
stations in every State, and by the instructions given through the agricultural
schools aided by the Federal Government and following the general curriculum
urged by the head and bureau chiefs of the Department.
The activities of the Department have been greatly increased by the
enactment of recent legislation, by the pure-food act, the meat-inspection
act, the cattle-transportation act, and the act concerning the interstate
shipment of game. This department is one of those the scope of whose action
is constantly widening, and therefore it is impossible under existing legislation
to reduce the cost and their estimates below those of preceding years.
FARMERS' INCOME AND COST OF LIVING.
An interesting review of the results of an examination made by the Department
into statistics and prices, shows that on the average since 1891, farm
products have increased in value 72 per cent while the things which the
farmer buys for use have increased but 12 per cent, an indication that
present conditions are favorable to the farming community.
I have already referred to the forests of the United States and their
extent, and have urged, as I do again, the removal of the limitation upon
the power of the Executive to reserve other tracts of land in six Western
States in which withdrawal for this purpose is now forbidden. The Secretary
of Agriculture gives a very full description of the disastrous fires that
occurred during the last summer in the national forests. A drought more
intense than any recorded in the history of the West had introduced a condition
into the forests which made fires almost inevitable, and locomotive sparks,
negligent campers, and in some cases incendiaries furnished the needed
immediate cause. At one time the fires were so extended that they covered
a range of a hundred miles, and the Secretary estimates that standing timber
of the value of 25 millions of dollars was destroyed. Seventy-six persons
in the employ of the Forest Service were killed and many more injured,
and I regret to say that there is no provision in the law by which the
expenses for their hospital treatment or of their interment could be met
out of public funds. The Red Cross contributed a thousand dollars, and
the remainder of the necessary expenses was made up by private contribution,
chiefly from the force of the Forest Service and its officials. I recommend
that suitable legislation be adopted to enable the Secretary of Agriculture
to meet the moral obligations of the Government in this respect.
APPROPRIATION FOR FIRE FIGHTING.
The specific fund for fighting fires was only about $135,000, but there
existed discretion in the Secretary in case of an emergency to apply other
funds in his control to this purpose, and he did so to the extent of nearly
a million of dollars, which will involve the presentation of a deficiency
estimate for the current fiscal year of over $900,000. The damage done
was not therefore due to the lack of an appropriation by Congress available
to meet the emergency, but the difficulty of fighting it lay in the remote
points where the fires began and where it was impossible with the roads
and trails as they now exist promptly to reach them. Proper protection
necessitates, as the Secretary points out, the expenditure of a good deal
more money in the development of roads and trails in the forests, the establishment
of lookout stations, and telephone connection between them and places where
assistance can be secured.
The amount of reforestation shown in the report of the Forest Service--only
about 15,000 acres as compared with the 150 millions of acres of national
forests--seems small, and I am glad to note that in this regard the Secretary
of Agriculture and the chief of the Forest Service are looking forward
to far greater activity in the use of available Government land for this
purpose. Progress has been made in learning by experiment the best methods
of reforesting. Congress is appealed to now by the Secretary of Agriculture
to make the appropriations needed for enlarging the usefulness of the Forest
Service in this regard. I hope that Congress will approve and adopt the
estimate of the Secretary for this purpose.
DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE AND LABOR.
The Secretary of the Department of Commerce and Labor has had under
his immediate supervision the application of the merit system of promotion
to a large number of employees, and his discussion of this method of promotions
based on actual experience, I commend to the attention of Congress.
THE CENSUS BUREAU.
The taking of the census has proceeded with promptness and efficiency.
The Secretary believes, and I concur, that it will be more thorough and
accurate than any census which has heretofore been taken, but it is not
perfect. The motive that prompts men with a false civic pride to induce
the padding of census returns in order to increase the population of a
particular city has been strong enough to lead to fraud in respect to a
few cities in this country, and I have directed the Attorney-General to
proceed with all the vigor possible against those who are responsible for
these frauds. They have been discovered and they will not interfere with
the accuracy of the census, but it is of the highest importance that official
inquiry of this sort should not be embarrassed by fraudulent conspiracies
in some private or local interest.
BUREAU OF LIGHT-HOUSES.
The reorganization of the Light-House Board has effected a very considerable
saving in the administration, and the estimates for that service for the
present year are $428,000 less than for the preceding year. In addition,
three tenders, for which appropriations were made, are not being built
because they are not at present needed for the service. The Secretary is
now asking for a large sum for the addition of lights and other aids to
the commerce of the seas, including a number in Alaska. The trade along
that coast is becoming so important that I respectfully urge the necessity
for following his recommendation.
BUREAU OF CORPORATIONS.
The Commissioner of Corporations has just completed the first part of
a report on the lumber industry in the United States. This part does not
find the existence of a trust or combination in the manufacture of lumber.
The Commissioner does find, however, a condition in the ownership of the
standing timber of the United States, other than the Government timber,
that calls for serious attention. The direct investigation made by the
Commissioner covered an area which contains 80 per cent of the privately
owned timber of the country. His report shows that one-half of the timber
in this area is owned by 200 individuals and corporations; that 14 per
cent is owned by 3 corporations, and that there is very extensive interownership
of stock, as well as other circumstances, all pointing to friendly relations
among those who own a majority of this timber, a relationship which might
lead to a combination for the maintenance of a price that would be very
detrimental to the public interest, and would create the necessity of removing
all tariff obstacles to the free importations of lumber from other countries.
BUREAU OF FISHERIES.
I am glad to note in the Secretary's report the satisfactory progress
which is being made in respect to the preservation of the seals of the
Pribiloff Islands. Very active steps are being taken by the Department
of State to secure an arrangement which shall protect the Pribiloff herd
from the losses due to pelagic sealing. Meantime the Government has secured
seal pelts of the bachelor seals (the killing of which does not interfere
with the maintenance of the herd), from the sale of which next month it
is expected to realize about $450,000, a sum largely in excess of the rental
paid by the lessee of the Government under the previous contract.
COAST AND GEODETIC SURVEY.
The Coast and Geodetic Survey has been engaged in surveying the coasts
of the Philippine archipelago. This is a heavy work, because of the extended
character of the coast line in those Islands, but I am glad to note that
about half of the needed survey has been completed. So large a part of
the coast line of the archipelago has been unsurveyed as to make navigation
in the neighborhood of a number of the islands, and especially on the east
side, particularly dangerous.
BUREAU OF LABOR.
The Commissioner of Labor has been actively engaged in composing the
differences between employers and employees engaged in interstate transportation,
under the Erdman Act, jointly with the Chairman of the Interstate Commerce
Commission. I can not speak in too high terms of the success of these two
officers in conciliation and settlement of controversies which, but for
their interposition, would have resulted disastrously to all interests.
TAX ON PHOSPHOROUS MATCHES.
I invite attention to the very serious injury caused to all those who
are engaged in the manufacture of phosphorous matches. The diseases incident
to this are frightful, and as matches can be made from other materials
entirely innocuous, I believe that the injurious manufacture could be discouraged
and ought to be discouraged by the imposition of a heavy federal tax. I
recommend the adoption of this method of stamping out a very serious abuse.
Since 1868 it has been the declared purpose of this Government to favor
the movement for an eight-hour day by a provision of law that none of the
employees employed by or on behalf of the Government should work longer
than eight hours in every twenty-four. The first declaration of this view
was not accompanied with any penal clause or with any provision for its
enforcement, and, though President Grant by a proclamation twice attempted
to give it his sanction and to require the officers of the Government to
carry it out, the purpose of the framers of the law was ultimately defeated
by a decision of the Supreme Court holding that the statute as drawn was
merely a direction of the Government to its agents and did not invalidate
a contract made in behalf of the Government which provided in the contract
for labor for a day of longer hours than eight. Thereafter, in 1892, the
present eight-hour law was passed, which provides that the services and
employment of all laborers and mechanics who are now or may hereafter be
employed by the Government of the United States, by the District of Columbia,
or by any contractor or subcontractor on any of the public works of the
United States and of the said District of Columbia is hereby restricted
to eight hours in any one calendar day. This law has been construed to
limit the application of the requirement to those who are directly employed
by the Government or to those who are employed upon public works situate
upon land owned by the United States. This construction prevented its application
to government battle ships and other vessels built in private shipyards
and to heavy guns and armor plate contracted for and made at private establishments.
The proposed act provides that no laborer or mechanic doing any part
of the work contemplated by a contract with the United States in the employ
of the contractor or any subcontractor shall be required or permitted to
work more than eight hours a day in any one calendar day.
It seems to me from the past history that the Government has been committed
to a policy of encouraging the limitation of the day's work to eight hours
in all works of construction initiated by itself, and it seems to me illogical
to maintain a difference between government work done on government soil
and government work done in a private establishment, when the work is of
such large dimensions and involves the expenditure of much labor for a
considerable period, so that the private manufacturer may adjust himself
and his establishment to the special terms of employment that he must make
with his workmen for this particular job. To require, however, that every
small contract of manufacture entered into by the Government should be
carried out by the contractor with men working at eight hours would be
to impose an intolerable burden upon the Government by limiting its sources
of supply and excluding altogether the great majority of those who would
otherwise compete for its business.
The proposed act recognizes this in the exceptions which it makes to
"for transportation by land or water, for the transmission of intelligence,
and for such materials or articles as may usually be bought in the open
market whether made to conform to particular specifications or not, or
for the purchase of supplies by the Government, whether manufactured to
conform to particular specifications or not."
SUBSTITUTE FOR PENDING BILL.
I recommend that instead of enacting the proposed bill, the meaning
of which is not clear and definite and might be given a construction embarrassing
to the public interest, the present act be enlarged by providing that public
works shall be construed to include not only buildings and work upon public
ground, but also ships, armor, and large guns when manufactured in private
yards or factories.
PROVISION FOR SUSPENSION IN EMERGENCIES BY PRESIDENT.
One of the great difficulties in enforcing this eight-hour law is that
its application under certain emergencies becomes exceedingly oppressive
and there is a great temptation to subordinate officials to evade it. I
think that it would be wiser to allow the President, by Executive order,
to declare an emergency in special instances in which the limitation might
not apply and, in such cases, to permit the payment by the Government of
extra compensation for the time worked each day in excess of eight hours.
I may add that my suggestions in respect to this legislation have the full
concurrence of the Commissioner of Labor.
In view of the keen, widespread interest now felt in the United States
in a system of compensation for industrial accidents to supplant our present
thoroughly unsatisfactory system of employers' liability (a subject the
importance of which Congress has already recognized by the appointment
of a commission), I recommend that the International Congress on Industrial
Insurance be invited to hold its meeting in 1913 in Washington, and that
an appropriation of $10,000 be made to cover the necessary expenses of
organizing and carrying on the meeting.
BUREAU OF IMMIGRATION
The immigration into this country is increasing each year. A large part
of it comes through the immigrant station at Ellis Island in the City of
New York. An examination of the station and the methods pursued satisfies
me that a difficult task is there performed by the commissioner and his
force with common sense, the strictest fairness, and with the most earnest
desire to enforce the law equitably and mercifully. It has been proposed
to enlarge the accommodations so as to allow more of the immigrants to
come by that port. I do not think it wise policy to do this. I have no
objection to--on the contrary, I recommend--the construction of additional
buildings for the purpose of facilitating a closer and more careful examination
of each immigrant as he comes in, but I deprecate the enlargement of the
buildings and of the force for the purpose of permitting the examination
of more immigrants per day than are now examined. If it is understood that
no more immigrants can be taken in at New York than are now taken in, and
the steamship companies thus are given a reason and a motive for transferring
immigrants to other ports, we can be confident that they will be better
distributed through the country and that there will not be that congestion
in the City of New York which does not make for the better condition of
the immigrant or increase his usefulness as a new member of this community.
Everything which tends to send the immigrants west and south into rural
life helps the country.
I concur with the Secretary in his recommendations as to the amendments
to the immigration law in increasing the fine against the companies for
violation of the regulations, and in giving greater power to the commissioner
to enforce more care on the part of the steamship companies in accepting
immigrants. The recommendation of the Secretary, in which he urges that
the law may be amended so as to discourage the separation of families,
is, I think, a good one.
MISCELLANEOUS SUBJECTS NOT INCLUDED IN DEPARTMENTS.
BUREAU OF HEALTH.
In my message of last year I recommended the creation of a Bureau of
Health, in which should be embraced all those Government agencies outside
of the War and Navy Departments which are now directed toward the preservation
of public health or exercise functions germane to that subject. I renew
this recommendation. I greatly regret that the agitation in favor of this
bureau has aroused a counteragitation against its creation, on the ground
that the establishment of such a bureau is to be in the interest of a particular
school of medicine. It seems to me that this assumption is wholly unwarranted,
and that those responsible for the Government can be trusted to secure
in the personnel of the bureau the appointment of representatives of all
recognized schools of medicine, and in the management of the bureau entire
freedom from narrow prejudice in this regard.
THE IMPERIAL VALLEY PROJECT.
By an act passed by Congress the President was authorized to expend
a million dollars to construct the needed work to prevent injury to the
lands of the Imperial Valley from the overflow of the Colorado River. I
appointed a competent engineer to examine the locality and to report a
plan for construction. He has done so. In order to complete the work it
is necessary to secure the consent of Mexico, for part of the work must
be constructed in Mexican territory. Negotiations looking to the securing
of such authority are quite near success. The Southern Pacific Railroad
Company proposes to assist us in the work by lending equipment and by the
transportation of material at cost price, and it is hoped that the work
may be completed before any danger shall arise from the spring floods in
the river. The work is being done under the supervision of the Secretary
of the Interior and his consulting engineer, General Marshall, late Chief
of Engineers, now retired.
This leads me to invite the attention of Congress to the claim made
by the Southern Pacific Railroad Company for an amount expended in a similar
work of relief called for by a flood and great emergency. This work, as
I am informed, was undertaken at the request of my predecessor and under
promise to reimburse the railroad company. It seems to me the equity of
this claim is manifest, and the only question involved is the reasonable
value of the work done. I recommend the payment of the claim in a sum found
to be just.
DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA.
CHARACTER OF GOVERNMENT.
The government of the District of Columbia is a good government. The
police force, while perhaps it might be given, or acquire, more military
discipline in bearing and appearance, is nevertheless an efficient body
of men, free from graft, and discharges its important duties in this capital
of the nation effectively. The parks and the streets of the city and the
District are generally kept clean and in excellent condition. The Commissioners
of the District have its affairs well in hand, and, while not extravagant,
are constantly looking to those municipal improvements that are expensive
but that must be made in a modern growing city like Washington. While all
this is true, nevertheless the fact that Washington is governed by Congress,
and that the citizens are not responsible and have no direct control through
popular election in District matters, properly subjects the government
to inquiry and criticism by its citizens, manifested through the public
press and otherwise; such criticism should command the careful attention
of Congress. Washington is the capital of the nation and its maintenance
as a great and beautiful city under national control, every lover of his
country has much at heart; and it should present in every way a model in
respect of economy of expenditure, of sanitation, of tenement reform, of
thorough public instruction, of the proper regulation of public utilities,
of sensible and extended charities, of the proper care of criminals and
of youth needing reform, of healthful playgrounds and opportunity for popular
recreation, and of a beautiful system of parks. I am glad to think that
progress is being made in all these directions, but I venture to point
out certain specific improvements toward these ends which Congress in its
wisdom might adopt. Speaking generally, I think there ought to be more
concentration of authority in respect to the accomplishment of some of
these purposes with more economy of expenditure.
Attention is invited to the peculiar situation existing in regard to
the parks of Washington. The park system proper, comprising some 343 different
areas, is under the Office of Public Buildings and Grounds, which, however,
has nothing to do with the control of Rock Creek Park, the Zoological Park,
the grounds of the Department of Agriculture, the Botanic Garden, the grounds
of the Capitol, and other public grounds which are regularly open to the
public and ought to be part of the park system. Exclusive of the grounds
of the Soldiers' Home and of Washington Barracks, the public grounds used
as parks in the District of Columbia comprise over 3,100 acres, under ten
different controlling officials or bodies. This division of jurisdiction
is most unfortunate.
Large sums of money are spent yearly in beautifying and keeping in good
condition these parks and the grounds connected with Government buildings
and institutions. The work done on all of them is of the same general character--work
for which the Office of Public Buildings and Grounds has been provided
by Congress with a special organization and equipment, which are lacking
for the grounds not under that office. There can be no doubt that if all
work of care and improvement upon the grounds belonging to the United States
in the District of Columbia were put, as far as possible, under one responsible
head, the result would be not only greater efficiency and economy in the
work itself, but greater harmony in the development of the public parks
and gardens of the city.
Congress at its last session provided for two more parks, called the
Meridian Hill and Montrose parks, and the District Commissioners have also
included in their estimates a sum to be used for the acquisition of much
needed park land adjoining the Zoological Park, known as the Klingle Ford
tract. The expense of these three parks, included in the estimates of the
Commissioners, aggregates $900,000. I think it would lead to economy if
the improvement and care of all these parks and other public grounds above
described should be transferred to the Office of Public Buildings and Grounds,
which has an equipment well and economically adapted to carrying out the
public purpose in respect to improvements of this kind.
To prevent encroachments upon the park area it is recommended that the
erection of any permanent structure on any lands in the District of Columbia
belonging to the United States be prohibited except by specific authority
THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA IN VIRGINIA.
I have already in previous communications to Congress referred to the
importance of acquiring for the District of Columbia at least a part of
the territory on the other side of the Potomac in Virginia which was originally
granted for the District by the State of Virginia, and then was retroceded
by act of Congress in 1846. It is very evident from conferences that I
have had with the Senators and Representatives from Virginia that there
is no hope of a regranting by the State of the land thus given back; and
I am frank to say that in so far as the tract includes the town of Alexandria
and land remote from the Potomac River there would be no particular advantage
in bringing that within national control. But the land which lies along
the Potomac River above the railroad bridge and across the Potomac, including
Arlington Cemetery, Fort Myer, the Government experiment farm, the village
of Rosslyn, and the Palisades of the Potomac, reaching to where the old
District line intersects the river, is very sparsely settled and could
be admirably utilized for increasing the system of the parks of Washington.
It has been suggested to me by the same Virginia Senators and Representatives
that if the Government were to acquire for a government park the land above
described, which is not of very great value, the present law of Virginia
would itself work the creation of federal jurisdiction over it, and if
that were not complete enough, the legislature of Virginia would in all
probability so enlarge the jurisdiction as to enable Congress to include
it within the control of the government of the District of Columbia and
actually make it a part of Washington. I earnestly recommend that steps
be taken to carry out this plan.
There are a sufficient number of corporations enjoying the use of public
utilities in the District of Columbia to justify and require the enactment
of a law providing for their supervision and regulation in the public interest
consistent with the vested rights secured to them by their charters. A
part of these corporations, to wit, the street railways, have been put
under the control of the Interstate Commerce Commission, but that Commission
recommends that the power be taken from it, and intimates broadly that
its other and more important duties make it impossible for it to give the
requisite supervision. It seems to me wise to place this general power
of supervision and regulation in the District Commissioners. It is said
that their present duties are now absorbing and would prevent the proper
discharge by them of these new functions, but their present jurisdiction
brings them so closely and frequently in contact with these corporations
and makes them to know in such detail how the corporations are discharging
their duties under the law and how they are serving the public interest
that the Commissioners are peculiarly fitted to do this work, and I hope
that Congress will impose it upon them by intrusting them with powers in
respect to such corporations similar to those of the public utilities commission
of New York City or similar boards in Massachusetts.
I do not think the present control of the school system of Washington
commends itself as the most efficient and economical and thorough instrument
for the carrying on of public instruction.
The cost of education in the District of Columbia is excessive as compared
with the cost in other cities of similar size, and it is not apparent that
the results are in general more satisfactory. The average cost per pupil
per day in Washington is about 38 cents, while the average cost in 13 other
American cities fairly comparable with Washington in population and standard
of education is about 25.5 cents. For each dollar spent in salaries of
school teachers and officers in the District about 4.4 days of instruction
per pupil are given, while in the 13 cities above referred to each dollar
expended for salaries affords on the average 6.8 days of instruction. For
the current fiscal year the estimates of the Board of Education amounted
to about three-quarters of the entire revenue locally collected for District
If I may say so, there seems to be a lack of definite plan in the expansion
of the school system and the erection of new buildings and of proper economy
in the use of these buildings that indicates the necessity for the concentration
of control. All plans for improvement and expansion in the school system
are with the School Board, while the limitation of expenses is with the
District Commissioners. I think it would be much better to put complete
control and responsibility in the District Commissioners, and then provide
a board of school visitors, to be appointed by the Supreme Court of the
District or by the President, from the different school districts of Washington,
who, representing local needs, shall meet and make recommendations to the
Commissioners and to the Superintendent of Education--an educator of ability
and experience who should be an appointee of and responsible to the District
Among other items for permanent improvements appearing in the District
estimates for 1912 is one designed to substitute for Willow Tree Alley,
notorious in the records of the Police and Health Departments, a playground
with a building containing baths, a gymnasium, and other helpful features,
and I hope Congress will approve this estimate. Fair as Washington seems
with her beautiful streets and shade trees, and free, as the expanse of
territory which she occupies would seem to make her, from slums and insanitary
congestion of population, there are centers in the interior of squares
where the very poor, and the criminal classes as well, huddle together
in filth and noisome surroundings, and it is of primary importance that
these nuclei of disease and suffering and vice should be removed, and that
there should be substituted for them small parks as breathing spaces, and
model tenements having sufficient air space and meeting other hygienic
requirements. The estimate for the reform of Willow Tree Alley, the worst
of these places in the city, is the beginning of a movement that ought
to attract the earnest attention and support of Congress, for Congress
can not escape its responsibility for the existence of these human pest
The estimates for the District of Columbia for the fiscal year 1912
provide for the repayment to the United States of $616,000, one-fourth
of the floating debt that will remain on June 30, 1911. The bonded debt
will be reduced in 1912 by about the same amount.
The District of Columbia is now in an excellent financial condition.
Its own share of indebtedness will, it is estimated, be less than $6,000,000
on June 30, 1912, as compared with about $9,00,000 on June 30, 1909.
The bonded debt, owed half and half by the United States and the District,
will be extinguished by 1924, and the floating debt of the District probably
long before that time.
The revenues have doubled in the last ten years, while the population
during the same period has increased but 18.78 per cent. It is believed
that, if due economy be practiced, the District can soon emerge from debt,
even while financing its permanent improvements with reasonable rapidity
from current revenues.
To this end, I recommend the enactment into law of a bill now before
Congress--and known as the Judson Bill--which will insure the gradual extinguishment
of the District's debt, while at the same time requiring that the many
permanent improvements needed to complete a fitting capital city shall
be carried on from year to year and at a proper rate of progress with funds
derived from the rapidly increasing revenues.
I renew my recommendation that the claims of the depositors in the Freedmen's
Bank be recognized and paid by the passage of the pending bill on that
I also renew my recommendation that steps be taken looking to the holding
of a Negro exposition in celebration of the fiftieth anniversary of the
issuing by Mr. Lincoln of the Emancipation Proclamation.
CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION.
The Civil Service Commission has continued its useful duties during
the year. The necessity for the maintenance of the provisions of the civil
service law was never greater than to-day. Officers responsible for the
policy of the Administration, and their immediate personal assistants or
deputies, should not be included within the classified service; but in
my judgment, public opinion has advanced to the point where it would support
a bill providing a secure tenure during efficiency for all purely administrative
officials. I entertain the profound conviction that it would greatly aid
the cause of efficient and economical government, and of better politics
if Congress could enact a bill providing that the Executive shall have
the power to include in the classified service all local offices under
the Treasury Department, the Department of Justice, the Post-Office Department,
the Interior Department, and the Department of Commerce and Labor, appointments
to which now require the confirmation of the Senate, and that upon such
classification the advice and consent of the Senate shall cease to be required
in such appointments. By their certainty of tenure, dependent on good service,
and by their freedom from the necessity for political activity, these local
officers would be induced to become more efficient public servants.
The civil service law is an attempt to solve the problem of the proper
selection of those who enter the service. A better system under that law
for promotions ought to be devised, but, given the selected employee, there
remains still the question of promoting his efficiency and his usefulness
to the Government, and that can be brought about only by a careful comparison
of unit work done by the individual and a pointing out of the necessity
for improvement in this regard where improvement is possible.
INQUIRY INTO ECONOMY AND EFFICIENCY.
The increase in the activities and in the annual expenditures of the
Federal Government has been so rapid and so great that the time has come
to check the expansion of government activities in new directions until
we have tested the economy and efficiency with which the Government of
to-day is being carried on. The responsibility rests upon the head of the
Administration. He is held accountable by the public, and properly so.
Despite the unselfish and patriotic efforts of the heads of departments
and others charged with responsibility of government, there has grown up
in this country a conviction that the expenses of government are too great.
The fundamental reason for the existence undetected of waste, duplication,
and bad management is the lack of prompt, accurate information. The president
of a private corporation doing so vast a business as the Government transacts
would, through competent specialists, maintain the closest scrutiny on
the comparative efficiency and the comparative costs in each division or
department of the business. He would know precisely what the duties and
the activities of each bureau or division are in order to prevent overlapping.
No adequate machinery at present exists for supplying the President of
the United States with such information respecting the business for which
he is responsible. For the first time in the history of the Government,
Congress in the last session supplied this need and made an appropriation
to enable the President to inquire into the economy and efficiency of the
executive departments, and I am now assembling an organization for that
At the outset I find comparison between departments and bureaus impossible
for the reason that in no two departments are the estimates and expenditures
displayed and classified alike. The first step is to reduce all to a common
standard for classification and judgment, and this work is now being done.
When it is completed, the foundation will be laid for a businesslike national
budget, and for such a just comparison of the economy and efficiency with
which the several bureaus and divisions are conducted as will enable the
President and the heads of Departments to detect waste, eliminate duplication,
encourage the intelligent and effective civil servants whose efforts too
often go unnoticed, and secure the public service at the lowest possible
The Committees on Appropriations of Congress have diligently worked
to reduce the expenses of government and have found their efforts often
blocked by lack of accurate information containing a proper analysis of
requirements and of actual and reasonable costs. The result of this inquiry
should enable the Executive in his communications to Congress to give information
to which Congress is entitled and which will enable it to promote economy.
My experience leads me to believe that while Government methods are
much criticised, the bad results--if we do have bad results--are not due
to a lack of zeal or willingness on the part of the civil servants. On
the contrary, I believe that a fine spirit of willingness to work exists
in the personnel, which, if properly encouraged, will produce results equal
to those secured in the best managed private enterprises. In handling Government
expenditure the aim is not profit--the aim is the maximum of public service
at the minimum of cost. We wish to reduce the expenditures of the Government,
and we wish to save money to enable the Government to go into some of the
beneficial projects which we are debarred from taking up now because we
ought not to increase our expenditures.
I have requested the head of each Department to appoint committees on
economy and efficiency in order to secure full cooperation in the movement
by the employees of the Government themselves.
At a later date I shall send to Congress a special message on this general
I urge the continuance of the appropriation of $100,000 requested for
the fiscal year 1912.
CIVIL SERVICE RETIREMENT.
It is impossible to proceed far in such an investigation without perceiving
the need of a suitable means of eliminating from the service the superannuated.
This can be done in one of two ways, either by straight civil pension or
by some form of contributory plan.
Careful study of experiments made by foreign governments shows that
three serious objections to the civil pension payable out of the public
treasury may be brought against it by the taxpayer, the administrative
officer, and the civil employee, respectively. A civil pension is bound
to become an enormous, continuous, and increasing tax on the public exchequer;
it is demoralizing to the service since it makes difficult the dismissal
of incompetent employees after they have partly earned their pension; and
it is disadvantageous to the main body of employees themselves since it
is always taken into account in fixing salaries and only the few who survive
and remain in the service until pensionable age receive the value of their
deferred pay. For this reason, after a half century of experience under
a most liberal pension system, the civil servants of England succeeded,
about a year ago, in having the system so modified as to make it virtually
a contributory plan with provision for refund of their theoretical contributions.
The experience of England and other countries shows that neither can
a contributory plan be successful, human nature being what it is, which
does not make provision for the return of contributions, with interest,
in case of death or resignation before pensionable age. Followed to its
logical conclusion this means that the simplest and most independent solution
of the problem for both employee and the Government is a compulsory savings
arrangement, the employee to set aside from his salary a sum sufficient,
with the help of a liberal rate of interest from the Government, to purchase
an adequate annuity for him on retirement, this accumulation to be inalienably
his and claimable if he leaves the service before reaching the retirement
age or by his heirs in case of his death. This is the principle upon which
the Gillett bill now pending is drawn.
The Gillett bill, however, goes further and provides that the Government
shall contribute to the pension fund of those employees who are now so
advanced in age that their personal contributions will not be sufficient
to create their annuities before reaching the retirement age. In my judgment
this provision should be amended so that the annuities of those employees
shall be paid out of the salaries appropriated for the positions vacated
by retirement, and that the difference between the annuities thus granted
and the salaries may be used for the employment of efficient clerks at
the lower grades. If the bill can be thus amended I recommend its passage,
as it will initiate a valuable system and ultimately result in a great
saving in the public expenditures.
INTERSTATE COMMERCE COMMISSION.
There has not been time to test the benefit and utility of the amendments
to the interstate commerce law contained in the act approved June 18, 1910.
The law as enacted did not contain all the features which I recommended.
It did not specifically denounce as unlawful the purchase by one of two
parallel and competing roads of the stock of the other. Nor did it subject
to the restraining influence of the Interstate Commerce Commission the
power of corporations engaged in operating interstate railroads to issue
new stock and bonds; nor did it authorize the making of temporary agreements
between railroads, limited to thirty days, fixing the same rates for traffic
between the same places.
I do not press the consideration of any of these objects upon Congress
at this session. The object of the first provision is probably generally
covered by the antitrust law. The second provision was in the act referred
to the consideration of a commission to be appointed by the Executive and
to report upon the matter to Congress. That commission has been appointed,
and is engaged in the investigation and consideration of the question submitted
under the law. It consists of President Arthur T. Hadley, of Yale University,
as chairman; Frederick Strauss, Frederick N. Judson, Walter L. Fisher,
and Prof. B. H. Meyer, with William E. S. Griswold as secretary.
The third proposal led to so much misconstruction of its object, as
being that of weakening the effectiveness of the antitrust law, that I
am not disposed to press it for further consideration. It was intended
to permit railroad companies to avoid useless rate cutting by a mere temporary
acquiescence in the same rates for the same service over competing railroads,
with no obligation whatever to maintain those rates for any time.
SAFETY APPLIANCES AND PROVISIONS.
The protection of railroad employees from personal injury is a subject
of the highest importance and demands continuing attention. There have
been two measures pending in Congress, one for the supervision of boilers
and the other for the enlargement of dangerous clearances. Certainly some
measures ought to be adopted looking to a prevention of accidents from
these causes. It seems to me that with respect to boilers a bill might
well be drawn requiring and enforcing by penalty a proper system of inspection
by the railway companies themselves which would accomplish our purpose.
The entire removal of outside clearances would be attended by such enormous
expense that some other remedy must be adopted. By act of May 6, 1910,
the Interstate Commerce Commission is authorized and directed to investigate
accidents, to report their causes and its recommendations. I suggest that
the Commission be requested to make a special report as to injuries from
outside clearances and the best method of reducing them.
VALUATION OF RAILROADS.
The Interstate Commerce Commission has recommended appropriations for
the purpose of enabling it to enter upon a valuation of all railroads.
This has always been within the jurisdiction of the Commission, but the
requisite funds have been wanting. Statistics of the value of each railroad
would be valuable for many purposes, especially if we ultimately enact
any limitations upon the power of the interstate railroads to issue stocks
and bonds, as I hope we may. I think, therefore, that in order to permit
a correct understanding of the facts, it would be wise to make a reasonable
appropriation to enable the Interstate Commerce Commission to proceed with
due dispatch to the valuation of all railroads. I have no doubt that railroad
companies themselves can and will greatly facilitate this valuation and
make it much less costly in time and money than has been supposed.
FRAUDULENT BILLS OF LADING.
Forged and fraudulent hills of lading purporting to be issued against
cotton, some months since, resulted in losses of several millions of dollars
to American and foreign banking and cotton interests. Foreign bankers then
notified American bankers that, after October 31, 1910, they would not
accept bills of exchange drawn against bills of lading for cotton issued
by American railroad companies, unless American bankers would guarantee
the integrity of the bills of lading. The American bankers rightly maintained
that they were not justified in giving such guarantees, and that, if they
did so, the United States would be the only country in the world whose
bills were so discredited, and whose foreign trade was carried on under
The foreign bankers extended the time at which these guaranties were
demanded until December 31, 1910, relying upon us for protection in the
meantime, as the money which they furnish to move our cotton crop is of
great value to this country.
For the protection of our own people and the preservation of our credit
in foreign trade, I urge upon Congress the immediate enactment of a law
under which one who, in good faith, advances money or credit upon a bill
of lading issued by a common carrier upon an interstate or foreign shipment
can hold the carrier liable for the value of the goods described in the
bill at the valuation specified in the bill, at least to the extent of
the advances made in reliance upon it. Such liability exists under the
laws of many of the States. I see no objection to permitting two classes
of bills of lading to be issued: (I) Those under which a carrier shall
be absolutely liable, as above suggested, and (2) those with respect to
which the carrier shall assume no liability except for the goods actually
delivered to the agent issuing the bill. The carrier might be permitted
to make a small separate specific charge in addition to the rate of transportation
for such guaranteed bill, as an insurance premium against loss from the
added risk, thus removing the principal objection which I understand is
made by the railroad companies to the imposition of the liability suggested,
viz., that the ordinary transportation rate would not compensate them for
the liability assumed by the absolute guaranty of the accuracy of the bills
I further recommend that a punishment of fine and imprisonment be imposed
upon railroad agents and shippers for fraud or misrepresentation in connection
with the issue of bills of lading issued upon interstate and foreign shipments.
GENERAL CONCLUSION AS TO INTERSTATE COMMERCE AND ANTITRUST LAW.
Except as above, I do not recommend any amendment to the interstate-commerce
law as it stands. I do not now recommend any amendment to the anti-trust
law. In other words, it seems to me that the existing legislation with
reference to the regulation of corporations and the restraint of their
business has reached a point where we can stop for a while and witness
the effect of the vigorous execution of the laws on the statute books in
restraining the abuses which certainly did exist and which roused the public
to demand reform. If this test develops a need for further legislation,
well and good, but until then let us execute what we have. Due to the reform
movements of the present decade, there has undoubtedly been a great improvement
in business methods and standards. The great body of business men of this
country, those who are responsible for its commercial development, now
have an earnest desire to obey the law and to square their conduct of business
to its requirements and limitations. These will doubtless be made clearer
by the decisions of the Supreme Court in cases pending before it. It is
in the interest of all the people of the country that for the time being
the activities of government, in addition to enforcing earnestly and impartially
the existing laws, should be directed to economy of administration, to
the enlargement of opportunities for foreign trade, to the conservation
and improvement of our agricultural lands and our other natural resources,
to the building up of home industries, and to the strengthening of confidence
of capital in domestic investment.